Current Litigation

IB legal must have sent him over in pursuit of more "facts", or they made him buy a license to look at the code.

"How ludicrous! They expect 'register_globals' to be turned off! This can't be our code!"
:)
 
My advice is to err on the side of being welcoming and not making anyone feel that their motives will be second-guessed without some evidence.

I tend to think the more vB folks who show up here as part of the community is a good thing. There is nothing to lose by being a good place to visit and there might be something to gain. If someone is not welcome or violating the TOS or the spirit of the site, the good mods here are well equipped to handle.
 
Why be hostile? xF has nothing to hide and don't forget, some of those vB staff are the same people we spoke to and worked with not too many moons ago, and AFAIK the legal claim wasn't brought about by the on-the-ground staffers, it was corporate stonewalling from high on above.

Hell, for all we know the vB staffers might be jealousy coveting xF and wishing they could completely re-write vB for the next release and let their coding skills fly - but have their hands tied by management or the company bean counters?!!!

Be cool <-- I'm sure that was in a film I saw recently ... Pulp Fiction? Samuel L. Jackson?

Anyway, I think it sums up the spirit of xF - we're here for the ride and the coding and the fun and the helping-each-other-out, not the Kudos of wearing the xF brand name!!!!

Cheers,
Shaun :D
 
Amused at the momentum and popularity that our Wacky Shirt Friday photo has gained here! Be nice boys!
Indeed, let's avoid hostility against the wacky-shirted. I'm sure that Manders, Adrian and the rest had no part in launching the law suits against XenForo, and as far as I can see their motivation is solely to improve and develop vBulletin to the best of their ability. Don't blame them for decisions made by senior managers.
 
I'm sure that Manders, Adrian and the rest had no part in launching the law suits against XenForo...

Well... for me as a paying customer of vBulletin (and once passionate community contributor over there) and XenForo I can tell that the trust that vBulletin tried to rebuild after the appalling vB4 'launch' was successfully squashed (for me... and obviously many others) by this announcement: http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/showthread.php/363883-Internet-Brands-claims-against-Xenforo. This was posted by mr. Adrian Harris (but yes signed as 'Internet Brands', so one could read it as it come from upper 'management'). However, when one reads this The Register article: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/10/05/vbulletin_sues_ex_employees/, then again it's Mr. Harris himself who is clearly stating:

Adrian Harris, current senior operations manager at vBulletin, told The Register that he was not able to provide us with a copy of the suit, but he confirmed that it was filed on Monday. Though the suit arrived a day before XenForo was set to launch a beta version of its new forum platform, he said that the two events are unrelated. "The release date of XenForo had no bearing on when we filed the suit," Harris said. "We filed the suit based on when we had sufficient information to file the suit."

Asked to describe the intellectual property XenForo has allegedly violated, Harris declined. "We hold the belief that technical aspects of the software utilize similar methodologies and things like that that are in vBulletin or due to be in vBulletin," he told us. Asked if XenForo was actually reusing vBulletin code, Harris again declined to say, but he indicated that this is covered in the suit itself.

For a simple customer/an 'outsider' this looks and sounds like Mr. Harris does indeed have a part and it made me seriously doubt the credibility/ethics of Internet Brands, especially after first reading former statements like these:

IB Adrian said:
If by "the management" you are referring to me, yes.
I think I speak for all of us in saying that Kier and Mike have done a really nice job with the software, and it is great to have a more competitive marketplace for forum software - I feel we all win from that.
(Source: http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/show...rum-software?p=2018505&viewfull=1#post2018505)
 
Adrian is the public mouthpiece for vBulletin and Internet Brands.
Yes, I realize this. That's also why I stated 'For a simple customer/an 'outsider' this looks and sounds...' (since one is not sure how to interpreted things/what/who is behind things).

The fateful announcement reads nothing like his writing style and very much like a certain somebody else's.
Yes, but for a non-insider this is obviously not clear.

I think it's clear from his comments before the suits were filed what his true opinions are.
After the specific announcement and outings though The Register I certainly am not sure as a paying customer what his true opinions are. And trust me if I say that I don't speak only for myself. Ofcourse you (as the insider :)) knows/understands more of the situation then any outsider could ever do, but for a simple customer like myself I can tell you it's highly confusing and worrying these kinds of things.
 
Amused at the momentum and popularity that our Wacky Shirt Friday photo has gained here! Be nice boys!

The shirts are fine, The treatment that I received from you in the past however was not.

That being said I would like to say welcome to XF and ask for your opinions on the court case, After all it would be rude of you to poke your head in only to encourage off-topic chat ;)
 
We are sometimes forced by our employers into doing things we either don't feel comfortable with or don't agree with at all.

We are also usually expected to toe the line and not present a contrary professional or personal opinion outwith the company.

It might leave a horrible taste in the mouth but it's not a difficult choice for most of us with families, mortgages, and bills to pay ... we go along with it because the moral high-ground has an expensive cost associated with it.

Unless there is anything that directly associates a vB staffer with the generation and application of the law suit, then we should welcome them here - they're just like us and get just as excited about good coding and great looking apps.

Geeks unite .... lol :)

Cheers,
Shaun :D
 
they can't say anything regarding the lawsuit, they're here as IB employees, it'd be like me asking a sony employee "hey champ, how do I jailbreak my PS3?" or even better, asking vBulletin "Howdy, how do I remove the piracy protection?" It's not done.

If you are suggesting that I should not have asked then I would disagree simply by the title of the thread
biggrin.png
 
Back
Top Bottom