I use an editor to make posts, occasionally with some text styling. I could do this in both.
I hated switching to the bbcode editor to insert a code snippet, but I haven't tried this with redactor so I don't know if it's any different. In any case, I voted redactor because it's working and I don't see a desire to revert to an editor we previously had when, regardless of the editor, people are always going to want a different one. Welcome to compromise.