Redactor or TinyMce?

[ibnesayeed]

I'd like to see a mixture of the two.

Yes, I want TinyActor.

And now we need a poll between TinyActor and RedMCE.

 

[Luxus]

When I get my hands on 1.2 I will style Redactor to look similar to TinyMCE and eventually make a guide, so this hopefully will satisfy people on both sides.

Here you go, just to show you how easy it is to customize redactor to your needs:

 

[Jeremy]

And now we need a poll between TinyActor and RedMCE.

But RedMCE doesn't have any funny one-liners (well, images) that @Brogan can use. In that respect, I think it shall lose in a landslide. lol

 

[Shelley]

Here you go, just to show you how easy it is to customize redactor to your needs:

View attachment 48068

HAHA Awesome. I say that in a way that you have showed the simplicity to customise.

 

[erich37]

I suggest people should wait a bit with criticizing the current Redactor-editor, until K+M have kicked the bugs out of it.
We all are very lucky that we have 2 of the best coders in the world who are actually able to do this. More waiting is required


For me the killer-feature of Redactor is the Drag-Drop capability, which is really great.
Just test it and you will see the innovation.

Changing the design of it with some sprite-images and CSS will be an easy deal.....


No complaining required.

 

[James]

I use an editor to make posts, occasionally with some text styling. I could do this in both.

I hated switching to the bbcode editor to insert a code snippet, but I haven't tried this with redactor so I don't know if it's any different. In any case, I voted redactor because it's working and I don't see a desire to revert to an editor we previously had when, regardless of the editor, people are always going to want a different one. Welcome to compromise.

 

[Teapot]

I voted Redactor because it's less buggy and more easily styleable in three days of being live than TinyMCE was in three years.

 

[Digital Doctor]

1. TinyMCE
2. Redactor
3. On the fence
4. Like to b**ch about editors, regardless how good all the current ones are. If Xenforo has X editors, I want X+1.

4 isn't for me, Cedric's TinyMCE tweaks were OK by me. Redactor seems even better.

 

[Digital Doctor]

Here you go, just to show you how easy it is to customize redactor to your needs:

View attachment 48068

Nice ! Make a new thread with this nice tweak.

The little bit of colour helps.
It's like the difference between a good cup of coffee and a cup of coffee with Bailey's Irish cream in it.

 

[Digital Doctor]

Before Prozac:

After Prozac:

 

[JABRONI]

Here you go, just to show you how easy it is to customize redactor to your needs:

View attachment 48068

Yeah, please make a thread showing us how to do that!

 

[(n)ickolas]

Here you go, just to show you how easy it is to customize redactor to your needs:

View attachment 48068

This actually looks really good @Luxus. Great work!

 

[AdamD]

Yea, the lack of colour is what kinda puts me off about the toolbar section of the editor, I know, it's a very minor thing, but the dark grey/grey look is kinda depressing!

I'd like to see the one here, themed like in the post above.

Is there a comparison table somewhere comparing the two editors?

 

[AdamD]

Hmm, nom nom nom, from the Redactor site:

 

[Sador]

The biggest thing that I dislike about the new editor, is the utter lack of colors. It looks like a big grey area with letters and stuff in it. I do think that's something that could be improved on.

 

[Digital Doctor]

The biggest thing that I dislike about the new editor, is the utter lack of colors. It looks like a big grey area with letters and stuff in it. I do think that's something that could be improved on.

The establishment says you can't say that.

 

[Sheldon]

TinyMCE looked lonely.

In all seriousness, the new editor is much smoother, and "fits" xF. TinyMCE just seemed to be missing the look and smoothness Redactor has.

 

[Digital Doctor]

The new editor is definitely better for me.
But no colour ?

 

[Sheldon]

The new editor is definitely better for me.
But no colour ?

The black/white color looks much better. Actually seems to update the look of it.

 

[Digital Doctor]

The black/white color looks much better. Actually seems to update the look of it.

Technically it's all shades of grey.
What's with the lame font and bold ?