I don't feel bad for Brogan.
I acknowledge he was absolutely awesome. ****ing hell, nearly 20,000 posts. That guy knew his stuff and he was dedicated. I salute him for that.
But I don't feel bad for him. He didn't HAVE to step down.
The place would be a happier place if, like 8thos just said, he bowed out quietly or just took a break and came back. No one would have blamed him for that.
Sadly, it was very public. Ultimately it has led to him tarnishing his reputation, and the poor bloke has had all sorts of rumours attributed to him that completely came from other people. I think people also took a dim view of the whole "I know everything, but I'm not going to tell you and I'm going to cause a crapstorm because Mike is my friend" post. Why cause a crapstorm then? Hardly a useful thing to do in public view of your "friend's" customers.
That being said, if differences were put aside and things moved on, it would be awesome to see him back here.