Ok here is what happened. I installed XF and made guest, registered, paid members. I never put the callback php file in the paypal IPN. I was using a paypal email that was tied to a different domain. I did not realize. Anyhow when a user would pay all of them wouold be added to the List Active Upgrades List, but not all would get moved to the Paid Members group. Is this because of the paypal address and IPN not set correct? I have since added a new paypal account and setup the IPN correctly. No payments yet to tell if fixed?????