Implemented Please put the Quote button back as a stand alone button in the editor toolbar

[AndyB]

Quoting text is a very often and important function in communicating on a forum. Placing the quote button under a drop down was a bad idea IMHO. Please put the Quote button back as a stand alone button which can be easily seen and clicked.

Thank you.

Please Like this post if you want to see this changed!

 

[Sheldon]

So, a Text Editor Button Choice Manager... it's settled. Hehehe.

 

[TPerry]

Bah.. mobile styles.... let's just pretend they don't exist - they're more annoying than anything else


Seriously though... I'm less likely to use Undo/Redo and Use BB Code Editor buttons, than I am to use the ones in the Insert button..... I vote for lumping those ones together and freeing the others.

Free Quote and Code buttons, I say!

Same here.. I very rarely use the table(s) or indent/outdent. Those would have made more sense to be in a drop down together IMHO.

 

[Chris D]

I think @Sheldon's idea is best.

 

[TPerry]

I think @Sheldon's idea is best.

Agreed... when will you have it done @Chris D?

 

[AndyB]

This is what the editor on my forum looks like. I have removed many icons that I don't want members using on my forum.

 

[AngelArs]

+1 for a separate quote button. I think sometimes when coders code they forget that newbies also have to use the software, and that they need to not fix what's not broken. After all, forums are supposed to be about communication, and anything that keeps it direct and simple is most welcome.

 

[Chromaniac]

Yup. One of the few annoyances in XF I noticed after migrating from IPB this week. I use Quote more than any other button on the toolbar. I mean even keyboard shortcuts would have been nice (I am still looking for creating a link).

 

[nodle]

I will say +1 for a quote button. I don't have a problem finding it and using it, but I could see where others that are use to other forums may.

 

[Chimpie]

The problem is the average forum user will not find the hidden Quote button and resort to other methods of highlighting quoted text. They resort to using bold, italics or using the quote character, all these make the post very difficult to read. In addition when the Quote button is not used, when a post is replied to the quoted text becomes part of the quote in the new post and it becomes very confusing what has been quoted and what is the authors own words.

And to add to this, not all quoted text comes from the site itself. We quote parts of articles quite frequently and having the quote button out front would be very useful.

You can easily rectify that by creating a thread and showing how so and so features work.

We're going to have to do that with several features after our migration this weekend.

 

[Pereira]

I'd prefer if all the buttons were placed individually instead of in drop-down menus. There is definitely enough room but the only thing holding it back is that it has to work on mobile too. It's one of the disadvantages of having a responsive theme.

The align buttons should also be opened up. The only drop-down choices there should be is for changing colour, font and size of text. I'd also put the undo and redo buttons to the right of the screen.

 

[Avensen]

Hidden Quote button creates a bad user experience, on many forums users often quote copy-pasted text from other sites. If there is limited space for buttons, we should show the Quote button and hide the rarely used Outdent/Indent buttons.

 

[whynot]

If there is limited space for buttons, we should show the Quote button and hide the rarely used Outdent/Indent buttons.

Agreed.
They are rarely(or never) used.

 

[whynot]

This is what the editor on my forum looks like. I have removed many icons that I don't want members using on my forum.

View attachment 72997

How did you do that, Andy?

 

[AndyB]

How did you do that, Andy?

You can use this add-on which gets you close to what looking the way the editor toolbar looks on my forum.

https://xenforo.com/community/resources/remove-editor-buttons.3628/

 

[rafass]

The best way should be that the admin decide what buttons use and where.

 

[whynot]

You can use this add-on which gets you close to what looking the way the editor toolbar looks on my forum.

Removes unwanted editor toolbar buttons.

Thanks, Andy but this addon removes them instead of changing their position.

 

[Dylan V]

I agree with that.

 

[viper357]

Quoting text is a very often and important function in communicating on a forum. Placing the quote button under a drop down was a bad idea IMHO. Please put the Quote button back as a stand alone button which can be easily seen and clicked.

Thank you.

Please Like this post if you want to see this changed!

Bump

 

[djbaxter]

I agree with most of the suggestions above. Quote is not a rarely used function. Some of the others which are not hidden are.

 

[Wildcat Media]

I think @Sheldon's idea is best.

Has anyone ever turned this into a suggestion?