I don't want to upset Michael or you Shelley, you both already decided to do what you did based on the principal of the matter and that is fine, but the fact remains that the contract gives you as the buyer of a 'lifetime license' legal rights, that is unless you accepted an updated EULA by taking any IB updates.
Bob Brisco could have not dreamed of a better way to deal with disgruntled and vocal customers than license cancellation, what I am trying to tell folks is not to give away their legal rights, the reason being, there might be legal action in the future that will force IB or whoever they eventually sell vB to, to provide value to the legacy license owners according to the original EULA for those who still have it.
What if Adobe buys vBulletin and offers vB 3 owners a new software deal ?
Do we know what is going to happen in the far future ?