Fred Sherman
Well-known member
I almost hate sharing this one...
Take a 1 in thick NY strip. Bring it to room temp. Season to taste, including kosher salt. Let it sit for 15 minutes after seasoning so that the salt draws out the water soluble proteins.
Place in a smoker (your choice of wood - i prefer mesquite) for 45 minutes. Smoker temp should not get above 185.
30 minutes in, heat a caste iron skillet over a turkey fryer burner on full blast.
After 45 minutes, place the NY strip in the skillet for 1 minutes on each side.
Let it rest for 10 minutes. At no point should you ever touch the meat with anything except a pair of tongs. No forks, not even the edge of a spatula.
Thats it.
The salt drew out the proteins. The smoke added flavor, but also dried the surface. The 900+ degree skillet caramelizes those proteins into a nice crust.
Cut into it, and its medium rare to medium, but still full of juices. It has a nice smoke ring. The low and slow smoke prep rendered fat and connective tissue, making it much more tender.
You can grill the steak if your grill uses cast iron grates, as mine does. It won't get as hot, so cooking time increases. Grill 90 seconds, then rotate 45 degrees and cook another 90 seconds. Flip and repeat. for 6 minutes total. You'll have nice grill marks. Every time you rotate or flip, move to a different part of the grill.
If you really want to make it something, pair it with a cheese soufflé, asparagus with hollandaise, and a double IPA.