XF 3 General Information & Discussion

My point is that regardless of the product, use/buy it (or don't) based on what it does today, not what it might do in the future.
There's always hope but when hope fails there's Discourse :giggle:

The car analogy is actually quite amusing because some cars now come with upgrades built in. The only issue is to use them you need to pay!
 
There's always hope but when hope fails there's Discourse :giggle:

The car analogy is actually quite amusing because some cars now come with upgrades built in. The only issue is to use them you need to pay!

I'm probably in the minority, but I don't like how Discourse looks or functions. Much prefer XF, so that's why I'd like to see some great news from the devs about the progress on ver 3.
 
I'm probably in the minority, but I don't like how Discourse looks or functions.
I don't think there are many people here who would disagree with that, I certainly wouldn't but Discourse is in the ascendency. It appeals more to people who view the internet on smart phones. It provides an experience more inline with what they have grown up with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rdn
Tesla doesn't change products yearly... but ya, they are shipping the same products from previous years (same as XenForo).

My point is that regardless of the product, use/buy it (or don't) based on what it does today, not what it might do in the future. If it doesn't suit your needs today, that honestly should be the end of the conversation (at least the one for today).
A 2026 Telsa model Y for example is a new product compared to its 2025 Tesla model Y. So yes - they are shipping new products yearly. (As I originally said).

More importantly, there is little question that Tesla is actively developing, manufacturing, and delivering at scale. That is the distinction I was making. The concern here for many that continuing voicing concerns is not simply whether XenForo works today, but whether the company has the resources and momentum to remain competitive and supported long term. For businesses investing significant time and money into a platform, that absolutely matters.
 
Last edited:
A 2026 Telsa model Y for example is a new product compared to its 2025 Tesla model Y. So yes - they are shipping new products yearly. (As I originally said).

But you can't upgrade to that 2026 model for a fraction of the cost to get those upgrades, or new features. Tesla also has plenty of customers willing to shell out top dollar for the new model year after year. Even if XF were releasing at a much faster rate I seriously doubt they'd get an incredibly dramatic increase in sales, and especially if everyone had to pay full price instead of just the cost of the renewal.
 
But you can't upgrade to that 2026 model for a fraction of the cost to get those upgrades, or new features. Tesla also has plenty of customers willing to shell out top dollar for the new model year after year. Even if XF were releasing at a much faster rate I seriously doubt they'd get an incredibly dramatic increase in sales, and especially if everyone had to pay full price instead of just the cost of the renewal.
It’s not about a dramatic increase in sales. It’s about consumer confidence in the long run to keep supporting the brand. Tesla was brought up as an analogy, and that company doesn’t have this issue. IMO that’s the main issue right now for Xenforo. More and more people seem to be leaving each year for example that used to make this community great.
 
Yeah like after waiting for 2 entire years after the tagreted release date, it should not be far away, right :)
Let It Go GIF by Holly Logan
 
Yeah like after waiting for 2 entire years after the tagreted release date, it should not be far away, right :)
Seems you can't stop lying. This thread is about 3.0. In the start posting of this thread you can read:
When is it available?
There is no release schedule at this time.
As you can't stop moaning about 2.4: The initial announcement for 2.4 on Sept 13th 2024 stated:

We are currently targeting a release between Q4 2024 and Q1 2025.
Clearly, given that we are in November 2024 now (so not exactly a match between Sept. 24 and "currently"), we are not yet 2 years outside this initally targeted frame and we all (well, obviously except you) know that it is yesterdays news, have understand and accaepted that the timeline has shifted a couple of times and it has never been a promise anyway. Wether we like it or not. Yes, it is embarrassing that the current target "some time in 2026" is about to run out as well and probably no one is happy about it. Still your continued destructiveness and insisting on information, that was outdated and overruled years ago already and insisting on this haven been a promise that it never was is tiring, the more as you post your tirades off topic in every thread you can get hold of. What do you expect to achieve by that?
 
to find out what is really causing the extreme delays
No one actually cares, nor does it matter.

Work continues on developing all products and work is prioritised accordingly. Each product update will be released when it meets our standards for quality and when we deem those updates to be complete.

Sometimes this takes longer than we originally aim for.
 
we are not yet 2 years outside this initally targeted frame and we all (well, obviously except you) know that it is yesterdays news

You continue to say things like this but what you're saying simply doesn't line up with the truth of all that actually happened here over the last several years. As this thread is about 3.0, and we know how you don't like threads being derailed and taken off-topic, here are a few posts, from the devs themselves, made years ago, that would have led any reasonable person to assume that we would not still be waiting on XF 3.0 to be released now and that, in fact, the original release date estimates are over two years old:

This post estimates that a 3.0 release date prior to October 2024 is probable:

If you renew now, you get 12 months of updates which will include XF 2.3 and probably XF 3.0.

What reasonable person could read that and not come to the conclusion that we've been waiting two years?

This post even mentions that, not only is it possible that 3.0 will be out in 2024, 3.1 might also be released in 2024! This is Chris, replying to the question: "Are you actually implying that XF 3 will be out in 2024?"

XF 3.0 will mostly include just the new style which needs a little more time to cook and so, yeah, that is the current target, but it is by no means a guarantee.

We've even had conversations where 3.1 might be released in 2024 too.

Again, what reasonable person could read that and not come to the conclusion that we've been waiting two years?

Another post from Kier, who mentioned 3.0 coming out in a "relatively short time" after 2.3 (which was released in July 2024). Again, this would have led any reasonable person to assume that we could see 3.0 before the end of 2024, early 2025, and we will in all likelihood surpass the two year-mark on either of those estimates, especially if 2.4 is still planned to release prior to 3.0.

The first of those releases will be XenForo 3.0. Right now, the only feature we are definitely pursuing for that release will be the new style and as such, we hope that 3.0 will follow 2.3 in a relatively short time, as it should be effectively 2.3+style. Once 2.3 is out, we'll be getting in touch with major XenForo style producers to help them get ready for the 3.0 style, so that by the time it's ready for release there should be good third party support ready to go.

Once again, what reasonable person could read that and not come to the conclusion that we've been waiting right around two years?

Then this post that shows that 2.4 is approaching, and will likely surpass, two years overdue. Considering 3.0 was originally announced before 2.4, again, it's reasonable to assume that 3.0 was pushed back even further by the introduction of 2.4 and that 3.0 is now overdue by over two years as well.

2.4 is not postponed, it is on target for “between Q4 2024 and Q1 2025” as we originally stated.

Again, what reasonable person, who understands that 3.0 was supposed to come before 2.4, could read that and not come to the conclusion that we've been waiting two years on 3.0?

So, you calling people liars, based on their own understanding of the developer's own words, is unfounded.

Now, I will concede to the fact that the XF devs did apologize for announcing 2.3 and 3.0 release estimates too soon. That doesn't, however, mean that XF 3.0 isn't delayed by more than two years. Clearly, it is.

Having said that, and as Chris said, things happen. My stance is still that I'd rather wait longer on a great product than get a good product faster. XF is still the best option for me and my site and, outside some major catastrophe here, I don't see that changing any time between now and when 3.0 comes out, regardless of how much longer we wait. I also trust that XF is doing the best they can to put out a quality product so I remain on, and in support of, Team XenForo. That confidence in, and loyalty to, XF, however, doesn't make me blind to the fact that things are not rolling along as quickly as we were led to believe they were back in 2023.

You can support a company and still be critical of the way they handle certain situations.
 
Didn’t take long for the cavalry to arrive…

View attachment 351091
Well, if you consider anyone who is tired by constant moaning, lies, off topic posts and destructiveness to be a fan boy: so be it, it's your opinion and it could barely be further from the truth.
But it leads to an interesting question: As you obviously consider yourself not as part of that brigade: What is the label you have for yourself and those alike?
Traditionally, on a forum, someone who constantly lies, moans, posts of topic and acts generally destructive for months over months would be called a troll. Yet this seems to be the forum culture and behavior that you are in favor of. So: What is the label you choose for the behavior that you seem to like so much?
 
I care. And it does matter because the long delays without reasons why undermine the trust in the company.

Communication helps you know. Just be honest why it takes so much longer than expected. The outcome is the same but a lot more people would understand.
If you really do care you wouldn't be one of the impatient members telling the staff here to rudely hurry up.

No one actually cares, nor does it matter.

Work continues on developing all products and work is prioritised accordingly. Each product update will be released when it meets our standards for quality and when we deem those updates to be complete.

Sometimes this takes longer than we originally aim for.
This here is an example of communication from one of the staff.
They're busy with getting 2.4 released.

What i love about being able to use this software is that it's simple to use.

Impatient people remind me of those honking their car horns at school pick up time or drop off time.
Or going in to your state/federal elections to vote.

Have some patience. It's better than being rude
 
Back
Top Bottom