XF 3 General Information & Discussion

Now, I will concede to the fact that the XF devs did apologize for announcing 2.3 and 3.0 release estimates too soon. That doesn't, however, mean that XF 3.0 isn't delayed by more than two years. Clearly, it is.
All good and valid points and you can even go further back. When the first HYS for 2.3 was initally posted back in September 2023 it turned out that the contents of that release had already shifted:

It's been a long time coming, and for various reasons that we will go into later, it has changed quite a bit from what we had originally intended it to be, but it's finally ready to start showing you what's new. (....)

This is not XenForo 3.0​

This is not the big design overhaul that was originally targeted for 2.3, which included sweeping changes to the template system and introduced a range of new technologies to provide a significant improvement to many areas of XenForo.

So in fact what we are waiting for with 3.0 today, still w/o a release date, was initially planned for 2.3. Which, as a release seems potentially not to have been deliverd in a very timely fashion after 2.2 as well (and delayed by inventing XF Cloud as an excuse). There is a thread dating back to 2022:

Jun 1, 2020 was the first 2.2 HYS released. So we are getting close/going past 2 years between feature releases now.

Where @Kier answered on July 11th 2022:
2.3 has been in active development for quite some time and we expect to start running HYS threads in the coming weeks.

The "coming weeks" should stretch quite a bit - in fact more than a year from there until the first HYS in September 2023 (and about two years until the release of 2.3).

We all know that XF's standard style is classic, but looked somewhat dated already years ago. 2.3 did not bring the intended overhaul, 2.4 was surprisingly announced as an intermediate release, a "tiny quality of life update, mainly consisting of the new editor" and should follow within few months after 2.3 and again a couple of months after that 3.0 was to be expected (mainly consting of the new style), if you believed the official communication back then.

2.4 was announced on Sept. 13th 2024 with the wording:

Coming soon: XenForo 2.4​

We are excited to announce the upcoming release of XenForo 2.4, bringing you exciting new features and improvements!

While XenForo 3.0 continues to be developed behind the scenes, we've decided to harness the team's enthusiasm and momentum to deliver an interim update that will enhance your XenForo experience sooner than you might have expected. (...)

Well: No, clearly not.

Awkwardly, we are now at the end of 2026 and are still waiting for 2.4, the intermediate, tiny quality of life update that was initally featured as

We are currently targeting a release between Q4 2024 and Q1 2025.
and containing things that were were supposed part of 3.0 apart from the style and to be released in a more stretched time frame than only shortly before 3.0 was communicated to be delivered. Once more scope had shifted (shrunk considerably) and the timeline had shifted as well. Yet still years later we are still waiting for that release.

If that teaches anything then that the XF crew seems notoriously overoptimistic regarding what they can achieve in which amount of time and that therefor any timeframe for targets/forecasts/releases, whatever you may call it, seem to be wishful thinking for the most part and can and should not be trusted. As this has been going on for years there is absolutely nothing new to it.

This would not harm too much if on an absolute scale delivery throughput would be considerable. But it isn't. Basically any other software company runs circles around them (including a lot of single developers) and a snail is a speedboat in comparison. Yes, quality takes it's time but this "speed" cannot be explained with quality standards in the slightest.

The same goes for the fact that communication from XF is abysmal at best. Has been for years, there has been no change and there is no reason to believe that there will be one in future. Everyone here on the forums is aware of that (and many if not most have been longer around here than me).

Am I happy about all that? No. Can I change it? Also no. So the consequence is easy: either I accept it or I leave and go for a different product. If there was a better product I would probably do so, just I am not aware of one and my desire for switching horses with all the work, the need for new learnings and the investments tied to it is not huge, to say it politely. The more as I am generally happy with XF as a product - it is the company behind it and the way they act that bothers and annoys me. It could be a brilliant product with stunning features and loads of enthusiastic customers - but this is destroyed by the behavior of the company and it's staff.

But clearly, in many aspects I am not a fan of how XF does things (as a company as well as within the product). It does not live up to expectations on today's standards any more, it looks dated, it is missing elementary features that are then deflected towards add ons (while the add on marketplace is a total mess in terms of quality of the products, reliability of the developers and neglected or orphaned offerings, lacking any quality standards and now got even worse through the ai-inflation).
The immense backlog of hundereds of open bugs has been neglected for years (not even lokked at as it seems) and continued to grow. Only recently it has been started to be categorized with the help of AI and while I am happy about that I do not follow some of the classifications.

Communication from the company or it's employees is basically non existent, unreliable and cynical or insulting at times. One can easily get the feeling that the XF crew not only lacks respect for their paying customers but rather considers them as an annoyance and disturbance, sometimes almost hating them - so being ignored as a customer sometimes seems in fact the most positive thing one can expect.

The customer forum is heavily undermoderated, still loaded with thousands of bots at any given time and a couple of spam posts every single day. Culture and participation have gone downhill over the last years. Not exactly a good show case.

Most of the features that the new versions aught to bring are of no relevance to me anyway (while features I'd like to see or consider elemenary will also clearly not or never be part of XF) - which does not matter anyway as feature releases have been delayed for years. My license extension that I stacked up before the last price increase years ago should have easily covered 2.4 and 3.0, even with the most pessimistic expectations, ran finally out in September this year w/o 2.4 even in sight (let alone 3.0) and I did not renew it as it would have felt foolish.

The new style that 3.0 is expected to bring may be already looking outdated, given that it's design has been finalized more than three years ago. This is a message from @Kier about the new design from July 2023:

However, as the design was finalised and the technology behind it was being integrated, we turned our attention to how to migrate existing styles over to the new system in as much as would be possible.

But the the message is dated as is anything else and within the same message there is this statement:

After 2.3, we will introduce our new release model, where we will target a single major new feature with each release. That's not to say that other features definitely won't make it because of course they will, but instead of having a big slate of functionality to introduce with each x.y release, we'll get that one major feature done and hit the release button. The intention is that we'll have much more regular feature releases.

The first of those releases will be XenForo 3.0. Right now, the only feature we are definitely pursuing for that release will be the new style and as such, we hope that 3.0 will follow 2.3 in a relatively short time, as it should be effectively 2.3+style. Once 2.3 is out, we'll be getting in touch with major XenForo style producers to help them get ready for the 3.0 style, so that by the time it's ready for release there should be good third party support ready to go.

Not exactly how it turned out to be. So possibly the new style got an overhaul in the mean time. Or not - I don't care, we haven't even seen it. I have simply given up on XF quite a while ago and do not expect much any more. The three reasons to stick with XF are the past investments, the lack of better alternatives and the fact that it works as it is now and seems technically pretty sound (including fast patches in case a security issue pops up). But hopes for improvements in the future that really make a difference? Not really.

All sympathies to the crew, being part of a small company and dealing with a lot of stuff. Most of the time I still believe they may have the best intentions - but the outcome is everything but convincing. What I've seen from them regarding communication, reliability, output and outcome over the last years is massively underwhelming. Not once, not twice but in a row over years. And they do not seem to recognize or acknowledge it let alone change it. It would be easy, necessary and is a very justified customer expectation and countless software teams around the world have proven that it is easily possible and has very positive effects - yet XF don't do anything despite the issues have been named really often enough for many years. As I don't believe they are incompetent fools it seems to be a matter of attitude. There are no consequences and they can't be held accountable either. Continuing the current way is the most comfortable way for them. Still the product is technically sound. So I use what I have and don't hope (let alone trust) in anything regarding future or any announcements from XF any more. I will appreciate if finally something will get delivered, but I don't wait for it any more. I wish I had reason to build up trust again, but instead I have to remind me to let go any hope and rather rely on what I have today, as limiting as it may be sometimes and not to get angry about it.
On the road of "love it, change it, leave it" I have for the time being clearly left behind "love it" for the most part, passed "change it" but not yet fully and confidently reached "leave it", as there are still some things to love regarding XenForo as a software. Still they are actively driving customers away - staying a customer due to a lack of viable alternatives is in my eyes not the best testimonial for a company or a product.

Still I see no reason to moan constantly in the forums in a destructive manner.

If that makes me a fan boy in the eyes of some weirdos: So be it. In fact I am rather the opposite.

You can support a company and still be critical of the way they handle certain situations.

I think we can allign here.
 
Last edited:
Well, if you consider anyone who is tired by constant moaning, lies, off topic posts and destructiveness to be a fan boy: so be it, it's your opinion and it could barely be further from the truth.
But it leads to an interesting question: As you obviously consider yourself not as part of that brigade: What is the label you have for yourself and those alike?
Traditionally, on a forum, someone who constantly lies, moans, posts of topic and acts generally destructive for months over months would be called a troll. Yet this seems to be the forum culture and behavior that you are in favor of. So: What is the label you choose for the behavior that you seem to like so much?
Gee, lighten up. Don’t get your XenForo undies in a bunch. :X3:
 
It is incredibly frustrating, and why I haven't bothered to renew in years until today. Because I literally have no idea how to plan my own site or customer site upgrade plans, as we never get any information that's actually reliable.

I don't doubt the team are doing their best and prioritising the right things, especially in this very fast moving landscape from the last 12 months, but it makes life very difficult for the customers when there's entire months or years between certain types of updates.

I reluctantly renewed one licence today just so I can upgrade PHP, so my hand was forced. One of them I just said **** it to, and blocked access to it when we had the big patch a few weeks ago because I don't want to waste time and money if 3.0 doesn't come out for another year.

I would just hope there's there's potentially some kind of gesture of good will or licence extension for the literal years later release than planned. But whatever, it is what it is. It was nice to get a new HYS though today, that was a very much appreciated bit of comms on progress from the team :)
 
And Kier hasn't posted anything substantial in almost 3 years. That doesn’t exactly inspire much confidence either.
So what?
Kier's been busy getting 2.4 done and dusted.

It is incredibly frustrating, and why I haven't bothered to renew in years until today. Because I literally have no idea how to plan my own site or customer site upgrade plans, as we never get any information that's actually reliable.

I don't doubt the team are doing their best and prioritising the right things, especially in this very fast moving landscape from the last 12 months, but it makes life very difficult for the customers when there's entire months or years between certain types of updates.

I reluctantly renewed one licence today just so I can upgrade PHP, so my hand was forced. One of them I just said **** it to, and blocked access to it when we had the big patch a few weeks ago because I don't want to waste time and money if 3.0 doesn't come out for another year.

I would just hope there's there's potentially some kind of gesture of good will or licence extension for the literal years later release than planned. But whatever, it is what it is. It was nice to get a new HYS though today, that was a very much appreciated bit of comms on progress from the team :)
You using this as an excuse for not renewing your license...
i renew each year. Why? You never know when the Staff here are going to be finished.
I do it also if i need to ask a question directly towards one of the staff.
I get my answers and i respect the staff here even more.
I'm just glad they all post.
Because that's part of communication too.
 
I would just hope there's there's potentially some kind of gesture of good will or licence extension for the literal years later release than planned

Your license includes 12 months of updates.

In the past 12 months, we've seen the following updates released:
... plus multiple levels of back-ported patches for all versions back to 2.2.0
 
Clearly, given that we are in November 2024 now
I think you meant 2026?

No one actually cares, nor does it matter.

Work continues on developing all products and work is prioritised accordingly. Each product update will be released when it meets our standards for quality and when we deem those updates to be complete.

Sometimes this takes longer than we originally aim for.
Indeed, quality first, always.
 
Your license includes 12 months of updates.

In the past 12 months, we've seen the following updates released:
... plus multiple levels of back-ported patches for all versions back to 2.2.0

And nearly all patches and minor bug fixes, which is fine, and appreicated. The problem arises when announcing features then waiting two years to release them when they're sitting in private repo somewhere getting stale and probably need getting revisited again by the time they're ready for release. At least with the current dev workflow improving I do have real hope for the true professionals like the Xf team to utilise them to their full potential and better plan their feature releases in reasonable time spans.
 
@smallwheels I and others have tried being real with the situation for years now…. Even after you've tried to mock us and call names. When will you finally come to your senses? You lack integrity at this point imo.
 
scenic route full of detours and returning back to base to figure out where the f the actual destination is, before jetting off again and then finding out that there is a different road so you go back to the start.

ultimately, it comes down to customers. renewing your licences means that this is the standard you accept.
 
It is incredibly frustrating, and why I haven't bothered to renew in years until today. Because I literally have no idea how to plan my own site or customer site upgrade plans, as we never get any information that's actually reliable.
That is a good point. I am not exactly eager for updates and had initially planned to go directly from 2.2 to 2.4, leaving out 2.3 to save on upgrade stress. With 2.4 being endlessly delayed I finally made the switch to 2.3 at the beginning of this year, mainly b/c some add ons I use had stopped updating their 2.2 versions anfter 2.3 came out. New features that I needed were only available on their 2.3 versions and within the 1,5 years since 2.3 was released until I upgraded the delta got pretty huge.
I do have some plans for customizing and builiding some elements specific to my forum - however: One of them depends from the custom fields search in 2.4 and with others I can't affort to shell out money only to have potentially to rework things shortly after and shell out time and money again when ever 2.4 and 3.0 finally arrive. The unreliability of XF makes it impossible to plan projects, extensions or investments for the own forum and I don't believe that I am the only one who has put many of those things on hold due to lack of a reliable planning ground.

So in fact the unreliability of XF's timelines is a business risk for forum owners, holds back investments and forum growth that would be enabled through them and the free lance and add on developers suffer from that holding back financially, too. It is indeed frustrating and annoying.
 
Back
Top Bottom