User Profile Data Under Avatar Not Showing

This is probably a terribly awful question, but how can I get things such as location, birthday, etc. showing below a users avatar?

Right now I just have the Avatar, username, and title. I've made sure that my test user and admin user have profile data entered and their privacy settings (set through the usercp) don't deny anything. Yet, for the life of me, I can't seem to find a way to get these things to show up in the thread display.