Lack of interest Suggestion: "Report Post" button

Enigma

Well-known member
Here's an idea to enhance the "Report post" button. When you click "Report", it pops up a menu with:
  • Spam
  • Personal Attack
  • Duplicate Post
  • Other...
If you click one of the first three, a bit of ajaxy goodness will report the post and you're done. If you click "Other..." then you get the current overlay where you type in a reason.

In the future the admin could specify/customise the items in the menu.

Just an idea to streamline the reporting process. :)
 

Shelley

Well-known member
Nice idea. Same principal as the contact form in vb where you can specify the problematic post. (y)
 

Eric J.

Well-known member
But if you clicked, say, Personal Attack, what if they were linked to the post and couldn't quite figure out what was wrong. At least with the text-box we can explain the situation no matter what situation it might be.
 

Shelley

Well-known member
could possibly have a checkbox other and then a field opens up and you can type what the problem is. If I read your post correctly.
 

Onimua

Well-known member
But if you clicked, say, Personal Attack, what if they were linked to the post and couldn't quite figure out what was wrong. At least with the text-box we can explain the situation no matter what situation it might be.
An optional checkbox that asks "Add comment?" that would load the textarea would fix that.
 

Enigma

Well-known member
But if you clicked, say, Personal Attack, what if they were linked to the post and couldn't quite figure out what was wrong. At least with the text-box we can explain the situation no matter what situation it might be.
If you want to explain the problem, click "Other..." The first 3 would be shortcuts to use when appropriate, otherwise you're free to explain. "Other.." could be renamed to "Explain..." as well.
 

Eric J.

Well-known member
I was thinking more like a Dropdown box with a bunch of different options (i.e. Spam, Flaming, Trolling, Other) and underneath a text-box. Just make both fields required and that would make it more certain of what was going on.
 

Enigma

Well-known member
That could work. What I was thinking was to make it simpler-- just one click (well, two) to report spam, etc, without having to type anything.
 

Eric J.

Well-known member
Lol or a can of Spam icon beside the number of each post that you click on, it then asks for confirmation and you can report Spam that easy. [/joke]
 

Mr_Bob

Well-known member
No idea if an infraction-type system is in here (which I hope so but who knows), but if it is maybe report reasons can be tied to different infractions. So, if the administrator has "Spam" as a listing, "Spam" can appear in the report post form. There can also be a set of options to decide whether or not an infraction reason will appear in the report post form (great for Spam First Offense, Spam Second Offense type infractions).
 

Jura

Member
Infraction systems are a good way to kill your forum's membership and to light up extra drama.
 

Grover

Well-known member
Infraction systems are a good way to kill your forum's membership and to light up extra drama.
This is exactly my experience. For example: everytime I log into vB4's User Settings over at vbulletin.com, or even worse: my own profile!, the mention of the infraction I got over there months ago, glances at me. It is not making me feel welcome, is it? I know more people feel like this. That's why I never activated the whole thing on my own platform. Again, I have contributed many suggestions to remove it at least from the profile, but it was never picked up.
 

Brandon_R

Guest
Yep when i get an infraction, i don't really feel to be active anymore as my time spent on the forum could be wasted easily. Instead we need a better way of handling it.
 

Brogan

XenForo moderator
Staff member
Agree on the infractions.

Nothing turns me off a forum quicker than that, especially expired ones that stay on your profile for ever.
 
F

Floris

Guest
Revisit it completely; consistency.

A report content module that's called when report is clicked, recognizing where you come from, offering an array of admin definable options and a reason input box.

This way it's consistent throughout the system. For users, threads/posts, conversations, profile comments, future~ blog, cms, gallery comments.
Perhaps the system can have content types, and the module recognizes if any new ones are there, offering their respectable admin area options.

This way improving on the report module will mean the improvements are throughout the system.
 

Jason

Well-known member
But if you clicked, say, Personal Attack, what if they were linked to the post and couldn't quite figure out what was wrong. At least with the text-box we can explain the situation no matter what situation it might be.
Chances are though, if the mod can't discern what was wrong with the post, then there isn't anything wrong with the post to begin with?
 

Dean

Well-known member
Is this a good place to suggest moving the 'report' button a bit? I almost clicked on it several times when 'liking' a post.
 

Mark.B

Well-known member
Never did like infractions. It's like being at school or work. I spend enough time being warned/told off in my work time, don't want to get it in my leisure time as well. So any forum that starts that infraction nonsense, I leave immediately.
 
Top