I finally decided to make the switch to Xenforo, and am more than happy that I did!
I can't say enough good things about this community - everyone has been very helpful. The migration was actually very easy (migrated over 1.2 million posts), and didn't even take that long. When I had questions, Chris and Brogan quickly responded to either my tickets or posts in this forum.
So far, all of my members love the new forum! I'm looking forward to getting my traffic back up to where it should be.
Thank you for creating such a great product!