[XFA] Medias Contest

[XFA] Medias Contest [Paid] 2.0.1

No permission to buy (€12.00)
XFA updated [XFA] Medias Contest with a new update entry:

New Features and bugs fixed

Bugs Fixed :
  • Bug with next and prev entry who roamed the entries of other contests
  • Bugs that allow to add new images at an edition of a entry surpassing the contest setup
New Features :
  • Watching categories :
    • Notifications by alerts and emails when a new contest is create
  • Watching contests :
    • Notifications by alerts and emails when
      • New entry is created
      • Contest is...

Read the rest of this update entry...
 
Is there a guide for this? I couldn't work out the demo. And if cannot, then my users cannot, making its usage very minimal.
Issues/questions I found or have:
  • Created a contest. Cannot see how to edit it afterwards
  • Display box for contest rules is ugly (text is extremely light, almost illegible, too large with lots of wasted space)
  • Cannot see any way (how or where) to make a submission/entry for the contest I created. (Edit: I see, contest permissions all defaulted to unticked. Silly!)
  • Appears new threads are created in the configured forum for every action. Yikes! One thread for creation, with the same thread used for submissions/votes/winners. All submitters and voters automatically subscribed/watching the (thread or contest) for notification of updates, submissions, and winners etc.
  • Is it optional to have the navigation link?
  • Have sub-nav items for 'Competitions I Entered' and 'Competitions I Voted'
  • Can the order of sidebar gadgets be changed? I would want 'Latest ...' above 'Top ...'
  • Having a sitewide sidebar widget is essential, promoting active competitions and submissions. Need to bring users from other areas of the site (forum resources, other add-ons) into Contests. Sidebar randomly displays xx submissions across all open contests allowing votes right there and then. When voted, the image disappears and is replaced with 'Click here to see more entries in this contest'. If no contests open for likes, then randomly rotates through submissions. If not active contests, randomly rotates between prior closed contests.
  • Does recurring contests create a new contest (copied from previous) for each new occurrence, or just reset/re-open the existing contest?
  • Usergroup A (Admin) can create new contests, and Usergroup M (Moderators) can only create new contests copied from prior contest(s). ie. manual repeats, not new from scratch.
  • Can you copy an existing contest as the template for creating a new contest? i.e. manual occurrence, instead of automated occurrence
  • Why does it show 'thumbnail' and 'full image' for insertion after uploading? Thumbnail and full image insertion into what?
  • Are only image uploads accepted? Can they not be URL's to hosted photos?
  • A contest entry/submission is displayed with 'Edit' 'Delete' 'Like' below it. Why show like if you do not have permissions to like, and/or likes are not yet open
  • Are all contest entry submitters automatically notified when the contest opens for likes?
  • Contest listings need a 'call to action' button titled 'discuss' that links to the created threads, so that users can discuss the contest/entries
  • Contest listings, on the right hand side, shows stats for both 'Contributors' and 'Entries' - what's the difference?
  • Can the Contests URL be changed from /medias-contest/ ? I would want /contests/ or /photo-contests/ etc.
Very excited about this, and has lots of potential. Will definitely buy once some of the usability issues above have been addressed.
 
Last edited:
This only for images or video content too?

Hi, Only images for the moment.

Is there a guide for this? I couldn't work out the demo. And if cannot, then my users cannot, making its usage very minimal.
Issues/questions I found or have:
  • Created a contest. Cannot see how to edit it afterwards
  • Display box for contest rules is ugly (text is extremely light, almost illegible, too large with lots of wasted space)
  • Cannot see any way (how or where) to make a submission/entry for the contest I created. (Edit: I see, contest permissions all defaulted to unticked. Silly!)
  • Appears new threads are created in the configured forum for every action. Yikes! One thread for creation, with the same thread used for submissions/votes/winners. All submitters and voters automatically subscribed/watching the (thread or contest) for notification of updates, submissions, and winners etc.
  • Is it optional to have the navigation link?
  • Have sub-nav items for 'Competitions I Entered' and 'Competitions I Voted'
  • Can the order of sidebar gadgets be changed? I would want 'Latest ...' above 'Top ...'
  • Having a sitewide sidebar widget is essential, promoting active competitions and submissions. Need to bring users from other areas of the site (forum resources, other add-ons) into Contests. Sidebar randomly displays xx submissions across all open contests allowing votes right there and then. When voted, the image disappears and is replaced with 'Click here to see more entries in this contest'. If no contests open for likes, then randomly rotates through submissions. If not active contests, randomly rotates between prior closed contests.
  • Does recurring contests create a new contest (copied from previous) for each new occurrence, or just reset/re-open the existing contest?
  • Usergroup A (Admin) can create new contests, and Usergroup M (Moderators) can only create new contests copied from prior contest(s). ie. manual repeats, not new from scratch.
  • Can you copy an existing contest as the template for creating a new contest? i.e. manual occurrence, instead of automated occurrence
  • Why does it show 'thumbnail' and 'full image' for insertion after uploading? Thumbnail and full image insertion into what?
  • Are only image uploads accepted? Can they not be URL's to hosted photos?
  • A contest entry/submission is displayed with 'Edit' 'Delete' 'Like' below it. Why show like if you do not have permissions to like, and/or likes are not yet open
  • Are all contest entry submitters automatically notified when the contest opens for likes?
  • Contest listings need a 'call to action' button titled 'discuss' that links to the created threads, so that users can discuss the contest/entries
  • Contest listings, on the right hand side, shows stats for both 'Contributors' and 'Entries' - what's the difference?
  • Can the Contests URL be changed from /medias-contest/ ? I would want /contests/ or /photo-contests/ etc.
Very excited about this, and has lots of potential. Will definitely buy once some of the usability issues above have been addressed.

Hi,
  • Created a contest. Cannot see how to edit it afterwards => Look the last screenshot, you have contest edit link
  • Display box for contest rules is ugly (text is extremely light, almost illegible, too large with lots of wasted space) => You can edit css rules to customize this box ( I think i will add styles properties in next version)
  • Cannot see any way (how or where) to make a submission/entry for the contest I created. (Edit: I see, contest permissions all defaulted to unticked. Silly!) => Contest permissions can be disable by an option in admin
  • Appears new threads are created in the configured forum for every action. Yikes! One thread for creation, with the same thread used for submissions/votes/winners. All submitters and voters automatically subscribed/watching the (thread or contest) for notification of updates, submissions, and winners etc. => There is an option to set up the appearance of threads (In a single thread or in each threads)
  • Is it optional to have the navigation link? => What navigation link ?
  • Have sub-nav items for 'Competitions I Entered' and 'Competitions I Voted' => Not actually
  • Can the order of sidebar gadgets be changed? I would want 'Latest ...' above 'Top ...' => Not actually
  • Having a sitewide sidebar widget is essential, promoting active competitions and submissions. Need to bring users from other areas of the site (forum resources, other add-ons) into Contests. Sidebar randomly displays xx submissions across all open contests allowing votes right there and then. When voted, the image disappears and is replaced with 'Click here to see more entries in this contest'. If no contests open for likes, then randomly rotates through submissions. If not active contests, randomly rotates between prior closed contests. => I can maybe create widgets for the next version
  • Does recurring contests create a new contest (copied from previous) for each new occurrence, or just reset/re-open the existing contest? => Create new contest ;)
  • Usergroup A (Admin) can create new contests, and Usergroup M (Moderators) can only create new contests copied from prior contest(s). ie. manual repeats, not new from scratch. => There is no function to copy a contest, the system is the recurrence for this.After I possibly add this feature in a future release
  • Can you copy an existing contest as the template for creating a new contest? i.e. manual occurrence, instead of automated occurrence => Nop see above
  • Why does it show 'thumbnail' and 'full image' for insertion after uploading? Thumbnail and full image insertion into what? => This is the standard behavior of attachments in XenForo, I use the templates by default and not personalized templates
  • Are only image uploads accepted? Can they not be URL's to hosted photos? => Only uploads yes
  • A contest entry/submission is displayed with 'Edit' 'Delete' 'Like' below it. Why show like if you do not have permissions to like, and/or likes are not yet open => Indeed it would be wise not to view it
  • Are all contest entry submitters automatically notified when the contest opens for likes? => Nop, only users who watch contest
  • Contest listings need a 'call to action' button titled 'discuss' that links to the created threads, so that users can discuss the contest/entries => There is a link that appears below the rules but in fact it is not very well placed
  • Contest listings, on the right hand side, shows stats for both 'Contributors' and 'Entries' - what's the difference? => Entry : Show entry informations, Contributor : Show user informations
  • Can the Contests URL be changed from /medias-contest/ ? I would want /contests/ or /photo-contests/ etc. => Yes with xF Route filters functionnality ;)

The add is young, so it is not perfect, so thank you to you to help us improve it ;)
 
You know, to Vote, it should appear randomly so it's more legit to it.
Agreed. Not should, but MUST. As it stands now, showing them in submission order puts far too much weighting on having submitted first/early and will drastically skew voting results.
 
On layout, the left sidebar shouldn't be displayed everywhere, makes sense on the contests homepage, but inside all contests and contest entries not really, that would give more space to the actual media entry on layout.
Agreed. And inside contests and contest entries, the sidebar on the right is moved to the left (for consistency of sidebar location across the whole add-on).
 
  • Is it optional to have the navigation link? => What navigation link ?
The main navigation. Perhaps I want users to access contests via the forum thread(s) created only.

  • Why does it show 'thumbnail' and 'full image' for insertion after uploading? Thumbnail and full image insertion into what? => This is the standard behavior of attachments in XenForo, I use the templates by default and not personalized templates
Highly confusing to users, thinking they have to insert the uploaded image into the submission.

  • Contest listings, on the right hand side, shows stats for both 'Contributors' and 'Entries' - what's the difference? => Entry : Show entry informations, Contributor : Show user informations
Can you explain further? Sorry, I still don't understand.
 
The main navigation. Perhaps I want users to access contests via the forum thread(s) created only.

You can disable event listener who manage navigation tab ;)


Highly confusing to users, thinking they have to insert the uploaded image into the submission.

I agree

Can you explain further? Sorry, I still don't understand.

What you do not understand?
Entry Informations: You have creation date of the entry, number of picture in entry, picture type (Picture Or Album) and number of vote
Contributor informations: You have Avatar from the submitter of entry and his username

Why are only the first 4 entries shown until paging functionality kicks-in?
For example, http://www.xen-factory.com/index.php?medias-contest/contest/blah.16/view
Plenty of space below the 4 entries (due to the sidebar greatly extending page height) to put more entries without needing paging functionality.

This is an option that you can configure. I just change the demo to put 8 entries per page ;)
 
Entry Informations: You have creation date of the entry, number of picture in entry, picture type (Picture Or Album) and number of vote
Contributor informations: You have Avatar from the submitter of entry and his username

Screen Shot 2016-01-29 at 19.40.21.webp

OK, think I understand now. So this contest has 7 entries from 2 users. Think I'd change the phrase from 'Contributors' to 'Users' or 'Entrants'
 
@XFA Can you clear up an issue for me please.

I created a demo competition and set the submission time to 20 days. I then set the vote period to 5 days.

Does this vote period start after the submission period has finished. If so something is wrong as it let me vote from the start of the competition.

It would seem sensible that if the vote period had not started yet then the "Like" button would not be visible.
 
Last edited:
@XFA Can you clear up an issue for me please.

I created a demo competition and set the submission time to 20 days. I then set the vote period to 5 days.

Does this vote period start after the submission period has finished. If so something is wrong as it let me vote from the start of the competition.

It would seem sensible that if the vote period had not started yet then the "Like" button would not be visible.

The voting period begins when the submission period is finished (except where you mix the two periods via checkbox).

To like link, suggest have been made above.

By cons normally if we are not in the voting period, it should appear a permissions error
 
The voting period begins when the submission period is finished (except where you mix the two periods via checkbox).

To like link, suggest have been made above.

By cons normally if we are not in the voting period, it should appear a permissions error

@Fredxd Ok I understand all that.

I have created a test competition on your test area and I did not select the "merge submission & voting" but now the competition is live.

When you click the "Like" button it is already adding a vote to the competition, even though the voting should not have started yet.

This is a link to the competition I created - http://www.xen-factory.com/index.php?medias-contest/contest/testing-voting-system.20/view
 
@Fredxd Ok I understand all that.

I have created a test competition on your test area and I did not select the "merge submission & voting" but now the competition is live.

When you click the "Like" button it is already adding a vote to the competition, even though the voting should not have started yet.

This is a link to the competition I created - http://www.xen-factory.com/index.php?medias-contest/contest/testing-voting-system.20/view

I note for next release ;)
 
Ok thanks @Fredxd

The next issue is that it says underneath who has liked/voted for the image ?

If this is how the voting process works then I wouldn't want people knowing who had voted for what image.

I would want the voters to be anonymous.

I appreciate you must be busy with other things but do you have any idea when you will be able to put some time into this add-on. I run a photography forum and this software would be brilliant for our competitions but as it stands now we could not use it.

As soon as its ready we would be purchasing.
 
Ok thanks @Fredxd

The next issue is that it says underneath who has liked/voted for the image ?

If this is how the voting process works then I wouldn't want people knowing who had voted for what image.

I would want the voters to be anonymous.

I appreciate you must be busy with other things but do you have any idea when you will be able to put some time into this add-on. I run a photography forum and this software would be brilliant for our competitions but as it stands now we could not use it.

As soon as its ready we would be purchasing.

For displaying voter I can make an option for hide or show voters

For anonymous voter I don't know if I can do this

And for ETA I can't give you sorry.
it really depends on the work I have in progress and other addons that I should update as well.
 
@Fredxd - thanks for your reply.

Sorry I may have confused the issue. I don't want the voters to be anonymous. I just don't want the voters to be seen by other members.

Your solution for adding an option to hide or show voters would be ideal.

If you could add this and correct the issue with people able to vote even though the vote is not open then I would be ready to purchase straight away.

Great add-on by the way :)
 
Back
Top Bottom