XF 1.3 Trophy criteria setting

[tonnyz]

I'd like to award :
A) 10 trophy points if a member have a "likes to messages ratio" of 1 while he is having 50-99 messages
B) 20 trophy points if a member have a "likes to messages ratio" of 1 while he is having 100-199 messages
PS: A member will receive all the 2 trophies (with an amount of 30 trophy points) if he gets each of them in each range of messages count.

I think I should set the criteria like this :
A)
User has posted at least X messages: 50
User has posted no more than X messages: 99
User likes to messages ratio is at least: 1
award: 10 trophy points

B)
User has posted at least X messages: 100
User has posted no more than X messages: 199
User likes to messages ratio is at least: 1
award: 20 trophy points

The current condition is :
User A has been awarded with trophy A and he is currently having 50 messages.

My questions are :

1) Will trophy A be revoked once user A's "likes to messages ratio" unexpectedly falls down to 0,5 while he is having 80 messages ?

2) Will trophy A be revoked once user A reaches 100 messages, since his messages count will currently not in the range of trophy A criteria (50-99) anymore.

3) If the answer of question #1 is "no", will he then get a duplicate trophy of trophy A if he get back his "likes to messages ratio" to 1 while still in the range of 50-99 messages ?

4) If my criteria setting above will cause any unwanted outcome, or if there is any other simpler criteria setting, how should I set it ?

thanks

 

[Paul B]

Once awarded, trophies are not revoked.

So the member will be awarded a trophy when they meet the criteria for the one related to 50 post count and then another one when they reach 100 posts.

 

[tonnyz]

Once awarded, trophies are not revoked.

So the member will be awarded a trophy when they meet the criteria for the one related to 50 post count and then another one when they reach 100 posts.

edited: nevermind, I got it

Thanks for your answer

 

[tonnyz]

Once awarded, trophies are not revoked.

Regarding this, How if the criteria is :
User has posted at least X messages: 100

A user got his trophy after he did spam-posting until 100 messages, which messages afterward are deleted by moderator- leaving only 70 messages there.

Will the very trophy be revoked ? I'm wondering if it would be a potential trouble if the trophy is not revoked automatically ?

 

[Mike]

Once a trophy is awarded, it will never be revoked. It represents a point-in-time achievement. This won't cause any issues.

 

[tonnyz]

Once a trophy is awarded, it will never be revoked. It represents a point-in-time achievement. This won't cause any issues.

oo, I see, thx