I miss Brogan as a mod. Not so much because of any "heavy hand" in moderating. Just because he was a ninja in sorting out problems and responding. (Not a dig at all on Jake/Lawewnce/Slavik or anyone else I am forgetting...they are all ninjas, too).
As far as complaints or issues about warnings or deleted posts/threads or whatever, I can't really comment. There seems to be minimal issues on this forum about drama or things that are moderated. (I might be wrong; it could be that I have not seen or paid attention to these issues...from what I have seen or have been aware of, I have not seen a lot of issues. If I am wrong, well, that is my ignorance).
To sum up, I think Brogan was a net plus to this forum. That said, to me, this site maintains the same value as before Brogan's exit as a mod: a great place to find out more about XF, and a place to discuss XF issues/questions.
(Should I be jealous that I have not been moderated before? Makes me wonder what I am missing, LOL).
Here is a radical idea: Let's use this site for its purpose.