Add-on *******'s Credits or xfRocks' Banking?

[Rigel Kentaurus]

I'm looking for some honest feedback. I am trying to implement a currency system on my forum.

The idea is that I seed an initial amount of "points" and then members can trade. Points will be awarded by the admin on events and not on automatically on actions (like, by posting)

I am evaluating this too, and both have good reviews, honest opinions from people using either are welcome

http://xenforo.com/community/resources/credits.1391/
http://xenforo.com/community/resources/bd-banking.536/

 

[imlps]

xfrocks gives very quick support or reply to your query as soon as he can, despite being webmaster or normal member on his forum.

Although I love Credits addon (as it provides a lot of rewarding events), sorry to say that ******* didn't take care of my issue like how xfrocks is (he is very dedicated).

And I think if your currency system is only meant for manually rewarding, then go with [bd] Banking since it's simpler.

 

[Rigel Kentaurus]

Yeah... I was thinking the same thing. In this particular case, simpler is better.

I have never used these points addons because they are a bit too invasive. They hook into the post system, message system, attachment system, views, downloads... omg. I am always afraid the next performance hit will come from there.

 

[intradox]

what about xfpoints?