Thank you for clarifying your position and updating your original post to make clear the background for the suggestion.I'm assuming you mean my signature link. Actually, the keyword advertising is something I make no use of and never have. Those who know my forum can check that - its a very educational student focused forum in a medical niche.
My main reason for suggesting this is actually for improving usability and participation. The are many industry specific terms on my site (currently on vB) so when terms and acronyms such as APH, PPH and others that I can define are shown in user created posts a mod automatically links those keywords to a glossary definition of the term - this allows users not so familiar with the terms to understand posts in the context of how they written. That is my only use of such a mod - Forgive me for feeling that many niche sites (ie, technical, medical, educational) could use something similar.
I added the keyword advertising / monetisation bits because frankly its an obvious 'other use' for the add on. I tried to think of all uses so that there were many carrots for development. For what its worth, the keyword advertising downsides as you mention I agree with, but thats not what I would personally use it for anyway - others might.
I'm a little insulted you find some warped alterior motive in my post feldon - I had the best of intentions and never thought for a moment it would be perceived that way. [edit] in fact, i have rewritten that post to remove keywords advertising references... people will discover monetisation uses anyway and maybe they should not be promoted so much, sorry.
and then your signature suggestion, and put two-and-two together as you were saying that xF should hold off on 'forum' feature bells and whistles until they address core requests and that you were putting forward your suggestion as something xF should be prioritizing. So it was in that vein that I responded.I would like to see a freeze on 'forum' feature bells and whistles being added and for the team to address some of the core barriers that are stopping some forums from migrating.
I see. But it should be instant as is normal in other forum software, not waiting 4-5 seconds each time an image link need to be pasted.Possibly.
But integrating a new editor is a huge task.
You only have to look at all the resolved bugs related to the current editor due to bugs with the editor itself or browsers to appreciate what would happen if the editor was changed.
I wish people would realize what they're really asking for here. Most of us have seen vB4's CMS system, and the mess that it is. We also likewise admire Wordpress or other similar systems, and wish that in xF's case we'd get something like that.For me a CMS and a basic gallery from Xenforo thats what i ask.
Fixed.We're asking Mike & Kier <snip>
Isn't Mike the more core programmer while Kier does the more front-end type work etc?Fixed.
A lot of people tend to overlook just how critical Mike's role is in developing XenForo.
CMS? That's a whole Universe of it's own. Install Joomla or even better, Wordpress, and bridge XF towards the latter.For me a CMS and a basic gallery from Xenforo thats what i ask.
Noooo... its not a priority, its a feature suggestion to improve usability mainly upon niche sites.... and that you were putting forward your suggestion as something xF should be prioritizing.
Oh, I definitely agree with that. xenPorta is actually a very very good step towards a CMS and its getting better all the time. Where it falls short is dependant on each individual site and modifying to suit a sites needs is way better than nothing and arguably way better than bridging a massive fully blown application. That said however, everyones needs are different.... But I still believe that chasing Wordpress and Joomla is counterproductive. They're too big, with too large a third party developer base. A CMS is as good as its plugins and modules and what people do with it. And nobody is doing a darn thing with the official vB CMS.
And galleries are already in existence as add-ons.
Well, I've imported all the albums from my old vB forum into the XF Albums add-on. Users love it, it's easy to use and it's not bloated with functions which are not really necessary. I've had PhotoPost Pro installed, but the users didn't like it at all. I don't blame them.There are not really comparable to IP.Gallery in features. There exist no import script so they are not really an option.
It's said that 10% of websites on the internet now use Wordpress. If XenForo is smart, they will tab into this market.
Vbulletin hasn't and will probably never tap into WordPress. They are too busy making their own CMS which is EXTREMELY crappy.
Here, this post (from another thread) pretty much sums up the whole of the issue:
Well, I've imported all the albums from my old vB forum into the XF Albums add-on. Users love it, it's easy to use and it's not bloated with functions which are not really necessary. I've had PhotoPost Pro installed, but the users didn't like it at all. I don't blame them.
xenforo should make their own editor instead of depending if the others editors fix (or don´t) their bugs
why? good browsers keep functionality....That would require them to make an update everytime a new browser came out which can get tiring.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.