Okay, is this just me losing my mind or when you edit the privileges and status criteria on a notice the whole system decides to stop showing notices altogether in any forum? (Yes I meet the privileges to see the notices)
At first I had the notice only showing to administrators, after changing the criteria of the notices to show to logged in users, registered, and administrators, it decided to not show the notice at all. Infact all notices were not showing.
This is really strange. :| I just removed all notices and then added a new notice with only admin rights, it worked fine. Going back in to the admin panel, I added permission for user is guest and user is logged in to view the notice and it has disappeared again.
I might try and install a fresh instance of xenforo and try this again.