Dan Allen
Active member
Assuming you're looking for feedback on that, it's WAY too confusing. Both the copy and the graphic need simplification.
The reason I posted my notes on how to work with smilies at this link to was to straighten out the material so I could change it to something good. I'd agree, way too confusing in the copy and the graphic.
Explanation of Why I Posted Confusing Copy and Graphic
In the Army, we called it field expedient. When I was in school in London, I heard people call things like this, "Doing it in a pinch."
Maybe confusing is good, because the smilies deal is confusing to anyone who is new to it. Is there anyone new to XenFor in the last 6 months who says it not confusing? If there is, I will delete my post in a heartbeat while awaiting the one from the who says it is not confusing. I would expect people with long term experience do not find the smilies confusing. I don't see how that helps the new guy, except as an example of the fact that they do work and they can be understood.
A Guide to XenForo Smilies
I could not find the steps to follow anywhere, I had to suss them out with the clues I found somewghat hap hazardly. Writing a guide to XenForo smilies at my company would be done by a team of programmers and PhD technical writers. It would take them a few weeks if it was a priority job, which they would schedule weeks ahead of when it was needed, and the result would be awesome. The engineer we had in that area is possibly the smartest person I ever met. She was a great communicator and her work always was perfect. I figured the PhD tech writers would stamp Good Job on her work, then head for beer, but they changed it a lot. At Even though she gave them a perfect guide, everything was correct, clear, nice graphics, well organized, no typos, easy to follow, I think the the tech writers changed almost every single word she used, made all new graphics, creating a guide I could not have envisioned, but saw right away, it made our software so much easier for someone unacquainted with it to learn what it does.
Criteria for Posting
My test before posting this was not,"is this a good guide?", because I do not think I could make a good guide if I spent a week on it, not compared to a really good guide. I also thought about Well Known Members and decided, their response to this will affect my reputation, but not the goal I had in posting this.
My Goal
My goal was to share my working notes, organized enough that they are more helpful posted than not posted.
My Experience on Smilie Road
When I started, my goal was to find put 100 smilies my boss's site over a period of a few days. I counted Shelly's at 103. I had a couple hundred up in a few hours. I had to do a few delete/reloads of the smilies to get them working, without having blanks or duplicates.
Needs to be Added to My Notes
The XML packaged with some of the smilies created a controversy that went something like this:
First Guy (Who Just Attempted Installing Smilies, came looking for help and maybe to vent):
How come when I did the installation precisely as instructed, using your xml, the smilies are not appearing?
2nd Guy (who released the smiles) :
The xml is right.
3rd Guy (Smilie Veteran): They work for me

First Guy (like later that day or next day)
No, I fixed 
your
XML, removing the leading slashes, and now they work when they didn't before!!!








2nd Guy (who released the smiles) :


3rd Guy (Smilie Veteran): They work for me


First Guy (like later that day or next day)














The reason I report this is when I installed those exact smilies that were being discussed, using the xml that came with the smilies, checked the xml and its effect when loaded, I got the same results at the first guy and removing the slashes fixed them on my system, And for me, contrary to installation guide when I removed the slashes, everything worked
My XenForo Installation Must Be Wrong, or the XML with the Smilies Would Have Worked with Slashes
I cannot remember which smilies had this situation (I think it was the embola smilies). I will develop steps to reproduce this problem, including the xml with and without leading shashes and the result from both, and post then here.
Removing the forward slashes might have made the installation problem worse.

Last edited: