What Ad Manager Add-On Would Suit My Forum Best?

[Solkiwi]

I am preparing to monetise a midsize forum and not sure what to choose to manage this.

Instead of adsense type advertising I am going to have a lot of different local businesses(in the 100s) so each ad must be managed individually.
There needs to be a lot of positioning options and the ability to target different areas of the forum.


These two pop out the most but I have no idea how they stack up comparatively(or if there is a better option out there):
https://xenforo.com/community/resources/ads-manager-by-siropu.4090/
https://xenforo.com/community/resources/ad-monetize-pro-with-dfp-support.4491/


P.S. I also want to create a rotating set of ad tiles at the top of the forum instead of a standard banner so if that is natively supported by any of the options that would be great!

 

[tajhay]

Siropu's addon by the length of the highway. Great functionality and support. Ive used both. Its not even a contest.

 

[sross]

As far as I can tell no xenforo ad systems support recurring paypal subscriptions. The last time I used an ad system that required ad buyers to always re-up their payment, they often couldn't be bothered and my revenue crashed. Ever since switching to a recurring payment method they leave the subscription in tact for years. I can't recommend my current system as it's out dated and I am trying to find a suitable replacement.

 

[rdn]

https://xenforo.com/community/resources/ads-manager-by-siropu.4090/