Suggestion Forums Clean Up

[ragtek]

It would be great, if already implemented features, things which makes no sense, etc.. would be moved from the suggestion forums.

IHMO this would make tracking of the requests much easier....

 

[Decent60]

When Mods find ones that have been already implemented, they move them out.
Although, it would be hard to determine what doesn't make any sense. Unless written in utter gibberish, a suggestion could make sense to many people but not those who are savvy in area. While it wouldn't make sense to the savvy people, it could lead to other ideas to implement something that is along those lines, but better.

 

[Paul B]

We do move them as they are implemented.
If you notice any, you can always report them and they will be dealt with.

As for features which make no sense, that's not really a judgement which can be made as what's important to one person isn't necessarily so to another.

 

[ragtek]

we have 1,275 threads....
I'm sure >200 can be closed/moved because there are already implemented or where the devs say "no that's something we will never include/make..."
OR: A suggestion that doesn't make sense: http://xenforo.com/community/threads/suggestion-turn-on-debug-mode.816/

 

[Decent60]

OR: A suggestion that doesn't make sense: http://xenforo.com/community/threads/suggestion-turn-on-debug-mode.816/

To me, it would make sense so that potential buyers could see how much load is being produced on this site. Therefor they can compare it to the load they have on their site and see the difference.
However, in doing so, XenForo team would have to mask some areas out, due to potential security risks (and it's doubtful that they would ever do that)

 

[Mike]

I would say ones like that example are quite few and far between; there are plenty that might be niche suggestions, but they're still valid. That forum is always going to grow, unless you just arbitrarily move suggestions out -- but based on what criteria, and where do they get moved to?

 

[ragtek]

You could create a own "sub board" for this threads.

After some time it will be really hard to track the suggestions without an "real filter system" (or at least with thread prefixes).

 

[Paul B]

You could create a own "sub board" for implemented / offtopic threads.

You do know there's an implemented/resolved forum?

http://xenforo.com/community/forums/implemented-resolved-suggestions.15/