As designed  Replying to a thread with more than 1 page


Well-known member
When you're replying to a thread of 2 or more pages and you're on the first page, your post gets inserted at the end of the current page. However, it should be inserted at the end of the thread. This is a cosmetic problem. The posts is actually inserted correctly in the database.


If you reply an there are replies by others, but you're on page 1, it will say above the quick reply there are more posts .. but the last few will get inserted on the page you are.


Well-known member
Don't you get a "Show the other posts" (can't remember the exact wording) link right above your inserted post?


XenForo developer
Staff member
Yeah, it should give you a notice that there are more post than we can display. If we got <= 3 posts, we don't display the message.

The thought being that if you're responding on a non-last page, you need to see your post but also don't necessarily want to use your place.