Many webhook actions don't seem to work

[Kirby]

Affected version

2.3.4

Unless I am missing smth. it seems like sending webhooks for the following actions does not work:

bookmark
upvote
downvote
poll_vote
react
unreact
report
warn

Digging through the code it looks like those actions are not implemented at all

 

[kolakube]

I use webhooks in my W*rdPress app and found the following after running some tests:

bookmark - not sending
upvote - works
downvote - works
poll_vote - not sending
react - works
unreact - works
report - works
warn - Sends update to user event, but no data about the warning

 

[Kirby]

upvote - works
downvote - works
react - works
unreact - works
report - works

That's interesting, which content type did you test?
Did you test individually, eg. the tested action (event) was the only enabled event?

 

[kolakube]

I've tested those for Posts and Profile Posts.

 

[Kirby]

Strange. I've tested react / unreact for Posts as well and it doesn't send anything but update is sent when adding / removing a reaction.

Could you test bookmark ?

 

[kolakube]

Ah, I forgot to include it in the original list. Could not get bookmark to send an update.

When I tested what "worked" I considered getting a response back as working.

For react you get the updated reaction total from the response, so that could be helpful. Not sure I saw anything similar from upvote/downvote.

 

[Kirby]

Now i am completely confused

Could you post a sample payload you got for react ?

 

[kolakube]

Now i am completely confused

Could you post a sample payload you got for react ?

stdClass Object
(
    [content_type] => post
    [event] => update
    [content_id] => 200
    [data] => stdClass Object
        (
            [allowed_content_vote_types] => Array
                (
                    [0] => up
                    [1] => down
                )

            [attach_count] => 0
            [is_first_post] =>
            [is_last_post] => 1
            [is_reacted_to] => 1
            [last_edit_date] => 0
            [message] => This is the message content
            [message_parsed] => This is the message content
            [message_state] => visible
            [position] => 1
            [post_date] => 1930423658
            [post_id] => 200
            [reaction_score] => 1
            [Thread] => stdClass Object
                (
                    [custom_fields] => stdClass Object
                        (
                        )

                    [discussion_open] => 1
                    [discussion_state] => visible
                    [discussion_type] => question
                    [first_post_id] => 203
                    [first_post_reaction_score] => 0
                    [Forum] => stdClass Object
                        (
                            [breadcrumbs] => Array
                                (
                                    [0] => stdClass Object
                                        (
                                            [node_id] => 1
                                            [title] => Main category
                                            [node_type_id] => Category
                                        )

                                )

                            [description] =>
                            [display_in_list] => 1
                            [display_order] => 1
                            [node_id] => 4
                            [node_name] =>
                            [node_type_id] => Forum
                            [parent_node_id] => 1
                            [title] => Questions
                            [type_data] => stdClass Object
                                (
                                    [allow_posting] => 1
                                    [can_create_thread] => 1
                                    [can_upload_attachment] => 1
                                    [discussion_count] => 1
                                    [forum_type_id] => question
                                    [is_unread] =>
                                    [last_post_date] => 1730423338
                                    [last_post_id] => 262
                                    [last_post_username] => user1
                                    [last_thread_id] => 136
                                    [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0
                                    [last_thread_title] => Test
                                    [message_count] => 2
                                    [min_tags] => 0
                                    [question] => stdClass Object
                                        (
                                            [allow_answer_voting] => 1
                                            [allow_downvote] => 1
                                        )

                                    [require_prefix] =>
                                )

                            [view_url] => https://xfdomain.com/forums/forum.4/
                        )

                    [highlighted_post_ids] => Array
                        (
                        )

                    [is_first_post_pinned] => 1
                    [is_search_engine_indexable] => 1
                    [last_post_date] => 1730420558
                    [last_post_id] => 262
                    [last_post_user_id] => 1704
                    [last_post_username] => user
                    [node_id] => 4
                    [post_date] => 1730420553
                    [prefix_id] => 0
                    [question] => stdClass Object
                        (
                            [solution_post_id] => 0
                            [solution_user_id] => 0
                            [allow_question_actions] => yes
                        )

                    [reply_count] => 1
                    [sticky] =>
                    [tags] => Array
                        (
                        )

                    [thread_id] => 136
                    [title] => Test
                    [User] => stdClass Object
                        (
                            [alert_optout] => Array
                                (
                                )

                            [avatar_urls] => stdClass Object
                                (
                                    [o] =>
                                    [h] =>
                                    [l] =>
                                    [m] =>
                                    [s] =>
                                )

                            [content_show_signature] => 1
                            [creation_watch_state] => watch_email
                            [email] => ojin@oinu.com
                            [email_on_conversation] => 1
                            [interaction_watch_state] => watch_email
                            [is_staff] =>
                            [location] =>
                            [message_count] => 2
                            [profile_banner_urls] => stdClass Object
                                (
                                    [l] =>
                                    [m] =>
                                )

                            [push_on_conversation] => 1
                            [push_optout] => Array
                                (
                                )

                            [question_solution_count] => 0
                            [reaction_score] => 1
                            [receive_admin_email] =>
                            [register_date] => 1730420505
                            [show_dob_date] => 1
                            [show_dob_year] =>
                            [signature] =>
                            [trophy_points] => 1
                            [use_tfa] =>
                            [user_id] => 1704
                            [user_title] =>
                            [username] => vince2
                            [view_url] => https://xfdomain.com/members/user.2/
                            [vote_score] => 1
                        )

                    [user_id] => 2
                    [username] => user
                    [view_count] => 8
                    [view_url] => https://xfdomain.com/threads/test.1/
                )

            [thread_id] => 136
            [User] => stdClass Object
                (
                    [alert_optout] => Array
                        (
                        )

                    [avatar_urls] => stdClass Object
                        (
                            [o] =>
                            [h] =>
                            [l] =>
                            [m] =>
                            [s] =>
                        )

                    [content_show_signature] => 1
                    [creation_watch_state] => watch_email
                    [email] => ojin@oinu.com
                    [email_on_conversation] => 1
                    [interaction_watch_state] => watch_email
                    [is_staff] =>
                    [location] =>
                    [message_count] => 2
                    [profile_banner_urls] => stdClass Object
                        (
                            [l] =>
                            [m] =>
                        )

                    [push_on_conversation] => 1
                    [push_optout] => Array
                        (
                        )

                    [question_solution_count] => 0
                    [reaction_score] => 1
                    [receive_admin_email] =>
                    [register_date] => 1730420505
                    [show_dob_date] => 1
                    [show_dob_year] =>
                    [signature] =>
                    [trophy_points] => 1
                    [use_tfa] =>
                    [user_id] => 1704
                    [user_title] =>
                    [username] => vince2
                    [view_url] => https://xfdomain.com/members/user.2/
                    [vote_score] => 1
                )

            [user_id] => 1704
            [username] => vince2
            [view_url] => https://xfdomain.com/posts/2/
            [visitor_reaction_id] => 1
            [vote_score] => 1
            [warning_message] =>
        )

)

 

[Kirby]

Thanks for the feedback.
But this was for an update event, not for react.

Can you post one for react?

 

[kolakube]

That is the data I receive after reacting to a post, which seems to make sense since I set post.react under the Posts content type and a post must be updated to set a new reaction_score.

 

[Chris D]

That’s correct but if you disabled post.react then you would still get this webhook because this is the post.updated webhook rather than post.react. It is triggered because the reaction score changes, but it’s not triggered only in that scenario.

We haven’t looked at this yet but we will.

 

[Kirby]

That is the data I receive after reacting to a post

As already pointed out by @Chris D you get this data for post.update, not post.react

So my question is still:
Do you actually get data for post.react, eg. if this is the only event you are listening to?

 

[kolakube]

Do you actually get data for post.react, eg. if this is the only event you are listening to?

No, it looks like only post.update is sent for reactions.

 

[Kirby]

Thanks for confirming this.

So if this doesn't work for you I think that the other events (unreact, upvote, downvote, report and warn) also don't work and you assumed they are working because you also had update enabled?

 

[est3ban129]

I try to make user.upgrades webhook in make.com but not work, if I use user.uopdate, forum is sending every few seconds empty signal to make.com and make.com spend my credits (1 per time) for nothing.

 

[Starbucks]

I use webhooks in my W*rdPress app and found the following after running some tests:

bookmark - not sending
upvote - works
downvote - works
poll_vote - not sending
react - works
unreact - works
report - works
warn - Sends update to user event, but no data about the warning

Why the * between W and R? Why not just "Wordpress"?

 

[kolakube]

Why the * between W and R? Why not just "Wordpress"?

A little joke if you've been following the WordPress drama over the past few months.

 

[Starbucks]

A little joke if you've been following the WordPress drama over the past few months.

Yeah I've seen some stuff from the WordPress drama, but I didnt know the W*rdpress expression haha

 

[kolakube]

So if this doesn't work for you I think that the other events (unreact, upvote, downvote, report and warn) also don't work and you assumed they are working because you also had update enabled?

To finally further confirm, the webhook actions (add post.delete) don't work on XenForo 2.3.6. I did get those confused with update which could be used for some, but @est3ban129's makes a good point that it may not be worth relying on post.update since it can send too many requests.