1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Allow Admin To Set Resource Discussion To A Forum

Discussion in 'Resource Manager Suggestions' started by digitalpoint, Apr 8, 2012.

  1. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    Was thinking it would be very useful if you could have the discussion tab of a resource actually be a forum (set on a per resource basis), rather than a thread for "major" resources (at some point trying to do support in a single thread becomes cumbersome). As an example, we have a Sphinx search system we built that has it's own support forum (which contains 2,405 posts spanning 207 threads). Mashing all those into a single massive support thread wouldn't be that useful.
    sami simo, Mijo, Kintaro and 11 others like this.
  2. Alfa1

    Alfa1 Well-Known Member

    Some resources already have a whole forum full of discussion threads related to these. In such case its not useful to only show 1 discussion thread under the 'discussion' tab.
    It would be very useful to associate a forum with the discussion tab. This way all threads related to the resource can be shown.

    Instead of entering the threadID to connect it to the tab, the forumID should be entered.
    3rd AnGle, Andrej, Kiwi and 5 others like this.
  3. Chris D

    Chris D XenForo Developer Staff Member

    This requires a pretty big change.

    I think ultimately what will happen is a custom tab manager. Either in the core or as an add on.
  4. Alfa1

    Alfa1 Well-Known Member

    I expect it will. But I think its a very necessary change.
    For example: Imagine that KAM decide they want to list the Enhanced Search product in the RM. The Enhanced Search product has the following forums:
    Discussion: Enhanced Search Support
    Suggestions: Enhanced Search Suggestions
    Bugs: Enhanced Search Bug Reports

    Just like here on XenForo.com there will be many sites with the same needs / situation, where tabs are needed for whole forums. (and also a tracker btw)
  5. Digital Doctor

    Digital Doctor Well-Known Member

    3rd AnGle likes this.
  6. CallieJo

    CallieJo Active Member

    This suggestion would be so useful in so many ways!

    Please count my vote...
    erich37 likes this.
  7. erich37

    erich37 Well-Known Member

    great suggestion (y)

    Related Suggestion:

  8. Vicki

    Vicki Active Member

    Excellent suggestion!
  9. Jainic

    Jainic Active Member

    +1000 from me :)
  10. CallieJo

    CallieJo Active Member

    Has anyone seen a solution for this?

    I'd like to change the discussion tab to link to whatever url I choose.

    • Link to an external support website (some authors prefer to offer support on their own site)
    • Link to an internal forum I create (some resources will need an organized support area with full forum options)
    • Creating a new tab and adding the links inside the content of the tab
    • Adding the links to the overall description

    Can we please have options?
    • Create a thread as now (for those who prefer)
    • Link a tab to whatever url you want it to (for the rest of us who need organization control)
  11. endnuen

    endnuen Member

    Where/how/when can I find out if this suggestion is taken seriously ?

    For your information: I posted a similar suggestion which was marked as duplicate. Here I wrote that:

    Actually it has been somewhat achieved with this addon - http://xenforo.com/community/resources/social-groups-by-waindigo.891/
    But actually I am not sure if that is the case.
  12. CallieJo

    CallieJo Active Member

    A few thoughts on a work-around:
    • Using .htaccess you could redirect each thread created to the proper forum. And place all threads created into a private forum. This would be tedious if you have a lot of resources.
    • Change the phrase for the download button to "Discuss Resource" and place the forum url there for the download url.
    Anyone else have any ideas?

    I'm still trying to come up with a solution that is the least confusing for end-users.
  13. endnuen

    endnuen Member

    vaultwiki, its really something. Very flexible in this regard. But maybe its just that I want category descriptions to be considered a content type in its own right, and Xenforo-crew doesnt - perhaps ?

    • htacess will not be something i am considering ... dont know why actually. Seeems very wrong way around it.

Share This Page