Okay, I wanted to add that title so Google will provide this as the only thread for Gamification for Xenforo, since none currently exist. Now to the questions. We have been building membership really well from Twitter followers and traffic has been high. My concern is retention. With 3,500+ members, we average 100 people per day and the last 2 days have been about half. I am wanting to find a way to continue the conversation and encourage people to come back. So I am turning to the other forums admins here. How do you do it? I put out a newsletter about every 2 weeks or so, we have a chatroom, I try to keep things lively and even built a special group for people who want to help out more than others. I have built the trophy system out, keep new content flowing as much as one can, and I feel like the community is solid. Maybe it just comes down to time and content that matters. Anyways, I am looking for ideas that I haven't considered. What keeps your members coming back?