Hey everyone.
I've been thinking a lot about where XenForo 3 could go, and I wanted to share some ideas that I think would genuinely push the platform forward. These are all things that should work fine on shared hosting or VPS.
This turns passive image viewing into active exploration. It works purely with JavaScript on the front end and coordinate-based storage on the back end — no heavy processing needed.
This could be a simple widget with configurable criteria, no cron-heavy logic, just a lightweight query with a randomized or engagement-sorted result set.
This is a pure front-end feature using a CSS clip-path or overlay technique. It would generate a surprising amount of interaction because people genuinely enjoy playing with comparison sliders.
This creates a shared goal and gives users a reason to come back and contribute. It also makes the media gallery feel like a living, community-driven space rather than a series of individual uploads.
The psychological effect is significant; knowing someone else is active in the same thread makes you more likely to participate.
When someone quotes or replies to a specific post, I'd like the thread view to show a small, expandable context bubble inline, a compact preview of the parent post that expands on click. This keeps the reading flow intact without forcing users to scroll up or lose their place.
It's not full-nested threading (which can get messy), but rather a lightweight contextual layer that makes long discussions far easier to follow.
This is just a calculated ratio stored as a lightweight meta value and updated periodically. It draws attention to active discussions and creates a self-reinforcing loop: people click on trending threads, which makes them trend more.
This is similar to how Medium handles inline highlights, but adapted to the forum context.
For threads that run into dozens of pages, this would be invaluable for newcomers who want to catch up without reading everything.
I've been thinking a lot about where XenForo 3 could go, and I wanted to share some ideas that I think would genuinely push the platform forward. These are all things that should work fine on shared hosting or VPS.
1. Real-Time Collaborative Threads (Live Co-Authoring)
I'd love to see a mode where multiple users can co-author a single post or wiki-style resource in real time, similar to how Etherpad works. Using operational transforms or CRDTs over WebSockets (with a long-polling fallback for shared hosting), this could be done entirely server-side with no external dependencies. Imagine collaborative guides, community FAQs, or group project threads where five people are editing simultaneously, and you can see each person's cursor. This would make XenForo a legitimate collaborative workspace, not just a discussion board.
2. Spatial/Canvas-Based Thread View
Instead of the traditional linear or flat thread layout, I'd love an optional "canvas view" where replies are arranged spatially, almost like a mind map. Users could drag reply nodes around, cluster related sub-conversations, and visually trace how a discussion branched. This could be rendered entirely client-side with SVG or Canvas, and the positional data would just be lightweight JSON stored per thread. For brainstorming or complex debates, this would be a game-changer.
3. Ambient Presence and Micro-Status System
I'd like to go beyond "User is online" to something more expressive. Think lightweight, ephemeral micro-statuses, like "deep in a thread," "writing a long reply," "lurking the gallery," or custom statuses that auto-expire after a set time. The forum would feel alive. This could be powered by simple heartbeat pings and stored in a fast cache layer (Redis, or even a flat-file on shared hosting with an SQLite fallback). No AI, just presence data done right.
4. Built-In Visual Timeline for Threads and Forums
I'd love a timeline view for any forum or thread, a horizontal, scrollable timeline that plots posts, milestones, and key events chronologically. For long-running community projects, ongoing stories, or historical forums, this would be incredibly useful. It's essentially a different rendering of existing data: post timestamps, sticky markers, and user-defined "milestone" tags. Pure front-end work with minimal back-end overhead.
5. Per-User Adaptive Interface Density
Rather than one-size-fits-all themes, I think XenForo 3 should let each user control the density of their interface on a sliding scale, from ultra-compact (think: Hacker News) to spacious and card-based (think: modern Reddit). This wouldn't be a theme switch; it would be a single CSS-variable-driven density slider that adjusts spacing, font size, avatar size, and layout proportionally. One theme, infinite density levels, and zero server load since it's all client-side.
6. Offline-First Progressive Web App Mode
I'd like XenForo 3 to ship as a full PWA with offline-first capabilities out of the box. Users could browse cached threads, draft replies, and queue reactions while offline; everything syncs when connectivity returns. Service workers handle the caching, and a simple conflict-resolution strategy (last-write-wins or user-prompted merge) handles the sync. This is huge for mobile users with spotty connections and costs the server nothing extra.
Media Gallery: From a File Dump to a Social Experience
1. Reaction Heatmaps on Images
I'd love to see a system where users can click directly on a region of an image to leave a pinned reaction or a micro-comment. Think of it like annotation layers. When you hover over an image, you'd see small, clustered reaction badges on specific areas, someone reacting to a detail in the background, someone else commenting on a specific element in the foreground.This turns passive image viewing into active exploration. It works purely with JavaScript on the front end and coordinate-based storage on the back end — no heavy processing needed.
2. Media "Spotlight" Rotation on the Forum Home
Instead of a static "latest media" sidebar, I'd love a Spotlight block that rotates featured media on a timed interval or on each page load, weighted by recent engagement (reactions, comments, and views). Gallery uploaders would actually have a reason to post quality content because visibility becomes a reward.This could be a simple widget with configurable criteria, no cron-heavy logic, just a lightweight query with a randomized or engagement-sorted result set.
3. Side-by-Side Comparison Viewer
For communities that deal with photography, artwork, builds, setups, or before-and-after content, a native comparison slider would be huge. A user uploads two images to an album, tags them as a comparison pair, and viewers get a draggable slider overlay to compare them.This is a pure front-end feature using a CSS clip-path or overlay technique. It would generate a surprising amount of interaction because people genuinely enjoy playing with comparison sliders.
4. Media Collections with Community Contribution
Right now, albums are personal. I'd like to see a Collection type, a curated, theme-based gallery that multiple users can contribute to (with optional moderator approval). Think of it as a collaborative album, such as "Best Sunset Photos 2026" or "Community Rig Showcase."This creates a shared goal and gives users a reason to come back and contribute. It also makes the media gallery feel like a living, community-driven space rather than a series of individual uploads.
5. Inline Media Reactions in Thread View
When someone embeds a gallery image in a thread post, I'd love for the media-specific reactions to be accessible right there in the thread, not just the post-level reaction. You'd see a small reaction bar directly beneath the embedded image. This bridges the gap between the gallery and the forum discussion, and it funnels engagement back into the media gallery without requiring users to navigate away.Thread View: Making Conversations Feel Alive
1. Live Presence Indicators in Threads
I want to see who's currently viewing or typing in a thread I'm reading. A subtle bar at the top, such as "3 members are viewing · 1 is typing," would make threads feel like live spaces. This could be handled with lightweight polling or a simple WebSocket fallback, and it would work fine on shared hosting with a short polling interval.The psychological effect is significant; knowing someone else is active in the same thread makes you more likely to participate.
2. Threaded Reply Previews (Nested Context Bubbles)
When someone quotes or replies to a specific post, I'd like the thread view to show a small, expandable context bubble inline, a compact preview of the parent post that expands on click. This keeps the reading flow intact without forcing users to scroll up or lose their place.
It's not full-nested threading (which can get messy), but rather a lightweight contextual layer that makes long discussions far easier to follow.
3. "Momentum" Indicators on Threads
A thread's engagement velocity should be visible. I'd love a small, dynamic badge on thread listings that shows momentum, something like a subtle flame icon or a rising-arrow badge when a thread is gaining replies faster than the forum average over the past hour.This is just a calculated ratio stored as a lightweight meta value and updated periodically. It draws attention to active discussions and creates a self-reinforcing loop: people click on trending threads, which makes them trend more.
4. Paragraph-Level Reactions in Long Posts
For long-form content like guides, reviews, or tutorials, I'd like users to be able to react to individual paragraphs or sections. Hovering near the left margin of a paragraph reveals a small reaction toggle. This gives authors granular feedback on which parts of their content resonated, and it gives readers a way to engage without writing a full reply.This is similar to how Medium handles inline highlights, but adapted to the forum context.
5. Dynamic Thread Summaries (Non-AI, Rule-Based)
Instead of relying on AI summarization, I'd love a rule-based thread digest that auto-generates a summary block at the top of long threads. The logic would be straightforward: surface the top 3–5 most-reacted-to posts, show the original post, flag any staff replies, and note the most recent reply. All of this is queryable from existing data with no AI involved.For threads that run into dozens of pages, this would be invaluable for newcomers who want to catch up without reading everything.
Upvote
0
