Not a bug User criteria 'secondary group' does not match XF1 behaviour (notices/user promotions)

[Xon]

Affected version

2.0.10

In XF1, the "Secondary user groups" and "Not in secondary groups " user criteria match the user's secondary user group list. Only.

However in XF2, "Secondary user groups" and "Not in secondary groups " match the primary user group and secondary user group list.

The issue is the use of the isMemberOf function which checks the primary user group and the secondary user groups

 

[Mike]

Can you screenshot where you're seeing these criteria (for notices/promotions)?

The default criteria in both XF1 and XF2 is "user is <NOT> a member of any of the selected user groups". (Internally, the criteria is known as user_groups/not_user_groups.)

The XF1 code does check the user's primary group as well.

 

[Xon]

@Mike apologies, it looks like I got confused when jumping between the entity-base criteria system and the Finder based criteria system.

This can get closed as not-a-bug.