[TH] Post Comments [Deleted]

[Sperber]

What issues are you having with 2.1? It seems to work fine for me.

Check this post, @Jon W : https://xenforo.com/community/threads/th-post-comments-paid.153862/post-1311926 . It´s a natural thing, that everyone who uses Comments or Q&A of course wants to make the whole thing complete with the other add-on. It´s absolutly imperative, that both add-ons are compatible with each other, otherwise..

<xf:if is="$xf.visitor.user_id">
  Unhappy, cursing the admin
<xf:if is="$xf.visitor.is_admin">
  Unhappy & cursing Themehouse and the developer involved
<xf:if is="!$xf.visitor.user_id">
  Unhappy, cursing the site and EVERYONE involved
</xf:if>

Got it?

 

[Sperber]

Another error found:

When you comment on a previous comment and the last commentlevel is already reached, the "Comment" Link still appears in the post. If you click it, nothing happens and you don´t receive a warning, that you can´t comment any further on the next deeper level - since there is none. Best would be to disable the comment-link in comments that have reached the deepest comment level.

 

[Jon W]

@Sperber Just to be clear, presumably these are also issues with XF2.0?

 

[Sperber]

@Sperber Just to be clear, presumably these are also issues with XF2.0?

Heck, good you´re asking - no, on 2.1. beta 6.

 

[Jon W]

Heck, good you´re asking - no, on 2.1. beta 6.

Interesting. Leave it with me...

 

[ThemeHouse]

ThemeHouse updated [TH] Post Comments with a new update entry:

Version 1.0.0 Patch Level 1 released

Bug fixes:

• Fixes issue with posts missing if [TH] Question and Answer Forums add-on installed (requires update to [TH] Q&A Forums)

Read the rest of this update entry...

 

[TVA]

Tried to update to the latest, it is stuck in limbo and nothing works...

Line 12: Unknown tag fa encountered. - Template name: public:thpostcomments_post_macros

One or more add-ons currently have actions pending and may be in an inconsistent state. Because of this, some errors may be suppressed and unexpected behavior may occur. If this does not change shortly, please contact the add-on author for guidance.

 

[Jon W]

Tried to update to the latest, it is stuck in limbo and nothing works...

Line 12: Unknown tag fa encountered. - Template name: public:thpostcomments_post_macros

One or more add-ons currently have actions pending and may be in an inconsistent state. Because of this, some errors may be suppressed and unexpected behavior may occur. If this does not change shortly, please contact the add-on author for guidance.

Oops. Looks like some XF 2.1 specific code sneaked in to our release. I've now updated the download, so please re-download and try again (or upload to XF 2.1!).

 

[picom]

does this have downvoting and upvoting options for replies and comments?

 

[xffutureuser]

Hello. I have just purchased this add-on. I am testing it on my testing website XF 2.1.0. I am not sure if it is just my install, but I see these issues:

1. The "Like" button. Wen i click on a "Like" button, all other comments are also liked. See the attached image. I clicked to like the first comment, where the arrow is, and then all the other comments are liked as well.

2. Text selection with too many "+Quote" and "Reply" buttons. when I select a text in the first comment, there are too many "+Quote" and "Reply" buttons. Shouldn't there be just one "+Quote" and one "Reply" button?

3. When the text in the last, 4th nesting depth is selected, the "+Quote" and "Reply" button doesn't show up.

4. All comments visible by default? I don't see an option to keep all the comments visible by default. I have to click in order to see the comment. Would it be possible to add that kind of option, please? Thanks.

 

[Jon W]

Hello. I have just purchased this add-on. I am testing it on my testing website XF 2.1.0. I am not sure if it is just my install, but I see these issues:

1. The "Like" button. Wen i click on a "Like" button, all other comments with the same user are also liked. See the attached image. I clicked to like the first comment, where the arrow is, and then all the other comments are liked as well.

2. Text selection with too many "+Quote" and "Replay" buttons. when I select a text in the first comment, there are too many "+Quote" and "Replay" buttons. Shouldn't there be just one "+Quote" and one "Replay" button?

3. When the text in the last, 4th nesting depth is selected, the "+Quote" and "Replay" button doesn't show up.

4. All comments visible by default? I don't see an option to keep all the comments visible by default. I have to click in order to see the comment. Would it be possible to add that kind of option, please? Thanks.

View attachment 194169

Thanks for this. It looks like there might be some issues with XF 2.1.

 

[Jon W]

3. When the text in the last, 4th nesting depth is selected, the "+Quote" and "Replay" button doesn't show up.

You should be able to change the maximum nesting depth in the options.

4. All comments visible by default? I don't see an option to keep all the comments visible by default. I have to click in order to see the comment. Would it be possible to add that kind of option, please? Thanks.

Thanks for your suggestion.

 

[Jon W]

does this have downvoting and upvoting options for replies and comments?

Having the Question and Answer Forums add-on installed as well allows for downvoting and upvoting replies, but not comments.

 

[xffutureuser]

You should be able to change the maximum nesting depth in the options.

Thanks for reply. I know I can change the comment depth. Up to 4, that is good. The thing is that in the last dept, see the attached image, you can see selected text but without the "+Quote" and "Reply" buttons. What I am saying is that it is not possible to reply to that comment in the last nesting depth.

 

[Jon W]

Thanks for replay. I know I can change the comment depth. Up to 4, that is good. The thing is that in the last dept, see the attached image, you can see selected text but without the "+Quote" and "Replay" buttons. What I am saying is that it is not possible to replay to that comment in the last nesting depth.

View attachment 194184

That is the way it is supposed to be as it is not possible to have a 5th nested level, so it is not possible to reply.

 

[xffutureuser]

Also what I have noticed is that the buttons "Attached files", "Preview", "Post comment", "Cancel" seems to be misaligned compare to regular reply box.

Also the "Preview" button is in white colour whereas in regular reply box has the colour dark blue. Someone could by mistake press "Cancel" thinking that that is a "Preview" button.

 

[xffutureuser]

That is the way it is supposed to be as it is not possible to have a 5th nested level, so it is not possible to reply.

Thanks for reply. I understand. I can't go to 5th nested level, that is way the "Comment" button is not present in the 4th nested level. That is OK, no problem there.

But I mean there is missing a button for just a regular reply, in a regular reply box down at the bottom. Like I can do in another nested levels. See the attached image, I clicked on "Reply" button in another nested level and that allows me to reply at the bottom in regular reply box.

 

[xffutureuser]

Regarding the alignment, if it could be possible please to make it from what is now:



to something more consistent with the stock design, something like this:

 

[xffutureuser]

Also the comment box probably wouldn't have to be that tall. I see XF is nicely trying to spare space wherever possible and even for normal replys XF is not using that tall box. Usually the comments are used for short answers where such a tall box is not necessary. Just and idea.



And to change it to this:

 

[xffutureuser]

Also I have noticed that after I post a comment under a comment, it is not sending me back to that comment I have just posted, but rather It is sending me to the top of the page. Maybe because that comment is hidden. Once there will be an option to show all comments, maybe then it will work.

When I post a first comment under a reply, there it works nicely, it does sends me back to that comment.