John917
Active member
My SPF and DMARC is working fine. However, after testing outbound mail on Xenforo ACP to my gmail, gmail, microsoft email, and xenforo says DKIM is failing.
Google screenshot:

Microsoft has similar results but with this added:
MxToolBox says it's ok though:

This is how my dns record looks like:

Anything I'm doing wrong? Any way to troubleshoot this further? I might just had the wrong key by accidentally changing it on xenforo though. So I redid it and updated my DNS and am waiting to see if it fixes it.
Also any idea why my confirmation emails take forever to send? When I use the "test outbound email" tool in Xenforo ACP, it sends instantly. When sending validation email, it takes like 3-5 minutes for it to deliver. Google on the other hand reports it send quickly but it didn't....

Also, the email that I'm using "noreply@website.com" is actually not even setup. So if people were to email it, I won't be receiving it. Not sure if this matters.
*Update
Showing valid on https://dkimcore.org/c/keycheck also.
Is the key generated by Xenforo 1024 or 2048 bit? Maybe it's 2048 bit and gmail/microsoft email don't support it?
Found something else interesting:
"Also any idea why my confirmation emails take forever to send? When I use the "test outbound email" tool in Xenforo ACP, it sends instantly. When sending validation email, it takes like 3-5 minutes for it to deliver. Google on the other hand reports it send quickly but it didn't...."

Google screenshot:

Microsoft has similar results but with this added:
Code:
header.from=website.com;
dkim=fail (invalid public key) header.d=website.com;
dkim=fail (signature did not verify) header.d=website.com; arc=pass (0 oda=0 ltdi=0 93)
MxToolBox says it's ok though:

This is how my dns record looks like:

Anything I'm doing wrong? Any way to troubleshoot this further? I might just had the wrong key by accidentally changing it on xenforo though. So I redid it and updated my DNS and am waiting to see if it fixes it.
Also any idea why my confirmation emails take forever to send? When I use the "test outbound email" tool in Xenforo ACP, it sends instantly. When sending validation email, it takes like 3-5 minutes for it to deliver. Google on the other hand reports it send quickly but it didn't....

Also, the email that I'm using "noreply@website.com" is actually not even setup. So if people were to email it, I won't be receiving it. Not sure if this matters.
*Update
Showing valid on https://dkimcore.org/c/keycheck also.
Is the key generated by Xenforo 1024 or 2048 bit? Maybe it's 2048 bit and gmail/microsoft email don't support it?
Found something else interesting:
"Also any idea why my confirmation emails take forever to send? When I use the "test outbound email" tool in Xenforo ACP, it sends instantly. When sending validation email, it takes like 3-5 minutes for it to deliver. Google on the other hand reports it send quickly but it didn't...."

Last edited: