Dealing with Off Topic posts or not

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Why does this post say "To view this content we need you to accept third party cookies"?

Before I can see/do anything. I have never seen this before in a post. In other places of course, but never in someone's post.
 
Why does this post say "To view this content we need you to accept third party cookies"?
It's because your browser has blocked third party cookies for this site and the post contains embedded content. I've had the exact same thing happen once here and if I recall correctly it was directly after an update was applied.
 
Current policy for us as a free-speech-based forum is to not touch off-topic posts or even say anything about them whatsoever. As people have said earlier in this thread, normal conversations may gradually and naturally shift to other things, and it's a mistake, both in terms of community handling and in terms of generating forum content, to butt in and yell at users about off-topic posting. If anyone wants to talk about the original topic again, they can always come in and say anything at any time.

We DO, however, have a rule against obnoxious thread derailments where someone comes in and posts something that goes completely against the natural conversation flow and has nothing to do with the original topic.
 
So it's free speech until it isn't?

Free speech does not necessarily mean anarchy.

https://intosanctuary.com/index.php?threads/transcript-the-website-that-all-of-us-now-need-the-most-is-gone.1166/ said:
Q: Well, if you restrict users’ freedom to post even just a little bit, are you really the free speech forum you claim to be?

A: The whole point of freedom of speech is to allow for as much open discourse and sharing of ideas as possible. And it’s a little hard to share ideas or even basically communicate when someone is spamming nasty pictures all over the forum. Thus, there must be limits of SOME kind. If there isn’t then it just devolves into a zoo with monkeys flinging poo at each other. Also, to use freedom as effectively as possible requires taking responsibility, not brushing it off. This is something that is not talked about nearly as often as it should be. Nowadays, people in the United States are becoming alarmingly comfortable with not doing the researching and critical thinking that freedom requires, but I digress a little there.
 
So it's free speech until it isn't?

The way I handle it, and the way the U.S constitution handles it, is that you have 99.9% free speech. Obviously there's some things you could say that would cause a lot of problems for yourself and others. Not a great idea to have that plastered all over your forum.
 
Last edited:
If a thread has been derailed i'd have a "thread hell" section where all the awful and derailed posts go to.
 
Back
Top Bottom