Oh I've tried challenges, they solve it at about a 20-25% rate. I'm constantly seeing them successfully flood our old, irrelevant threads, some from multiple decades ago. The block was a last resort.

I wish I could let real visitors though but it just hasn't worked out and I've been trying to mitigate it for weeks. The fact that I've not gotten any emails about getting blocked despite it being nearly 6 hours since implementing it says something. Will see how it goes.