• This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more.

New XenForo 1.1 feature, makes the forum at least 4% faster

Rigel Kentaurus

Well-known member
#1
When I read on the release notes that XenForo that we were getting templates as files ...
http://xenforo.com/community/threads/xenforo-1-1-0-beta-3-released.21678/#post-274157
I got excited. Finally. Would this mean the end for eval() .. plus, speed would probably increase. Then I started thinking .. should I be excited ?

So, I decided to throw in a benchmark. Let's jump to the results, and then I'll talk about the process.

The results

For the test environment that was used
Screen Shot 2011-10-18 at 8.57.54 PM.png

The objective

The objective of the test is measuring if, for the same set of data, in an isolated environment, loading the templates from files represents a change from loading them from the database, and measuring that by looking at load times.

The test consisted of loading several pages repeatedly, and measuring the load time for said pages, then changing to templates into files, and repeating the identical, same experiment, and measuring the load time.

The load time is considered from when the request is made until the last byte comes in.

The process

Hardware used

Intel Core 2 Duo CPU, 2.53 Ghz
4 GB DDR3 RAM
SATA hard drive 5400

Software used

CentOS Linux 5.6
PHP 5.3.6 with APC enabled
Mysql 5.5.9 Community
Apache 2.2

The XenForo installation

XenForo 1.1 beta 3 with
18,000 threads
300,000 posts
13,000 users

The machine is isolated from user access, it is a test environment, only the test engine has access to that. The test consisted of the following

Loading the home page, opening a forum, opening a thread, browsing a user profile

This test was simulated for 10 online active users, each of them doing the experiment for 10 times. This means that the sample data was taken from loading 10 X 15 times the home page (150 times)

Everything was in the same machine, there is no network traffic.

The pages were "warmed". This means, the experiment was run once to make sure any caches are set, the opcode optimizations were initialized and that the subsequent loads do not represent a "first load" experience that could add any bias to the sample.

The data shown in the tables is from the second experiment. The test was repeated 3 more times to measure if the results could be attributed to other conditions. All the subsequent tests render similar proportions of 4%

The details

These are the details for the test. From there you can read that, for example, the Home Page went from a best scenario of 292 ms to 230 ms, and from an average of 1259 to 1144

The throughput of the server was increased by roughly 0.1%, which means that you would be able to serve 0.1% more requests with this change.

Templates from database

Screen Shot 2011-10-18 at 7.08.22 PM.png

Templates from files

Screen Shot 2011-10-18 at 7.10.56 PM.png



Conclusion

Templates in files will give you a small performance increase, it is faster. "How much" will depend on your exact server setup.

If you are looking to squeeze the last bit of performance from your server this feature would be useful. It can't hurt and the only reason not to enable it is if you are short of disk space, you don't have APC anyway or you are finding a bug by using templates in files.

If you are looking to improve your server performance because you are already in trouble this will do you no good. If your pages are slow this will only make them less slow, not fast. For that, it is way better to just upgrade to a better server or profile the actual performance bottleneck.

The fact that this was added to XenForo proves the level of detail and attention that is put into the software. Few people will care about optimizing that last 0.1%
 

Marcus

Well-known member
#2
With the stock xenforo templates, template caching made my forum start page 14% faster (debug time: 0.096 seconds).

When I removed the rendering of lots of subforums on the forum start page in node_forum_level_2 to speed up xenforo, template caching made only a difference of 4% (debug time: 0.065 seconds)
 

marioman

Active member
#5
With the stock xenforo templates, template caching made my forum start page 14% faster (debug time: 0.096 seconds).

When I removed the rendering of lots of subforums on the forum start page in node_forum_level_2 to speed up xenforo, template caching made only a difference of 4% (debug time: 0.065 seconds)
debug return execute all queries again with explain, that's will make your forum slow
stop it if you don't need to check something
time execution in debug no mean anything, so don't rely on it
 

Marcus

Well-known member
#6
marioman, I use debut to check which configuration is faster. I don't use debug for check how fast a page is delivered in a non-debug mode.