Okay, so your point is your afraid that people without licenses will publish the content on pirate websites without author permission. My argument would be that a licensed member is just as, if not more, capable of doing that. However, legitimate customers are coming to this site and getting stifled by the permissions system in the addon section of the forum, if you want more sales and traffic (Addons and XenForo itself), I would recommend pulling that curtain down.
Also, don't talk to me about digital content value. I run a business based on digital products, as soon as you can match my *paying* customer base of 10,000 you can start talking to me like that.
Sounds nice doesn't it? Lets see how many pirate websites I can find that violate "usage licenses". I would bet money it's in the hundreds. Your not being realistic when you try to play by those rules, because pirates just dont care.
Your absolutely right, I should take my business elsewhere. Let me know what addons you've written so I can be sure to never use them.