Now in large part, the experiences have been quite good. The new forum was easy to style to our needs, and our members like the layout.
But a few considerations:
1. It's early in the game, but I haven't seen any noticeable growth in the number of daily postings, particularly for the largest forum (over 120,000 messages), though we seem to have more "Guests," so maybe we are being crawled again and people are checking us out.
2. The vB4 import process, done with XF 1.0.4, was mostly solid, but for some reason a substantial number of custom avatars vanished. Never figured this out, and didn't want to just import over and over again. I hope, over time, that currently active members will just fix this themselves.
3. The vB4 friendly URL redirect simply doesn't work. I know this is a third-party add-on, but I'm getting no love from the author in working through the problem. It's not that we have a lot of those old links, although people trying to get to us from a search engine listing will be disappointed. I wish we could get assistance on this to resolve.
So there you go. I call this an 85% positive report, but I wish we could solve problem #3, and maybe get some solutions for #2. Anyone? And, yes, I did post my reports in the vB4 Redirect add-on thread.