Just like vbulletin reputation lacks notifications & post visibility, it also lacks a moderation queue and a report function. I have added all that and much more and it makes my big board almost community moderated and without abuse. The reputation system drives up my post quality to the extreme, and quickly gets rid of trolls and problem makers.
XF has implemented notifications beautifully and its great that its a 1 click function.
- The likes system offers no possibility to let the community address inappropriate content. If a bad post is not reported, it does not affect the poster at all.
- If I hit the like button, then does that mean I like you, or find your avatar hot, or want to give you some kudos, or does it relate to post quality?
- It doesnt say if I like the post a little, average or if its my favorite.
- It does not give any way to let you know how to improve your posts or what I like about your post.
On forums content is king. Especially when it comes to SEO. I don't see how the likes function improves post quality.
The notifications do make XF very addictive.