Reply to thread

This is unlikely to change (at least in the short term) for technical reasons mostly. The situation is potentially ambiguous.


The situation is that once a user reaches a threshold, the action is applied for a specified period of time and the fact that this user is added to a group is logged. Them dropping below that threshold does not remove the warning action. (The action is applied for a specific time - what to do through natural expiration, "unnatural" expiration, and deletion is probably the crux of the issue.)


As the action is still applied, removing them from the group manually removes the group but the action is still applied. When it gets applied again, the automated changes system sees that it expects the user to already be in the group and does not add it again. Essentially, it allows a manual removal to override it.


This applies to all systems that programmatically add user groups (it's the "user group change" system).


Back
Top Bottom