It's pretty cool as a concept, but in practice--unless I'm missing something--you can't control the replies, so the voting items are intermixed with random discussion. For the voters, that makes for a confusing mess. I'm not sure what the solution is, or if there is one, but it doesn't quite work as presented. I suspect it's limited by Xenforo's basic infrastructure. I guess one solution would be that only the thread starter could add options, but that defeats the 'competition' aspect of the add-on. I think votable items and random replies being the same content type is the fundamental problem. This could be a cool Rankr type plug-in, which I think would be more universally useful. Still, can't complain--it works as described, but the basic architecture is flawed.
