How can I find out which template to edit?
Using your browser, view the page source and look for a line of code near the top of the page which begins <div id="content" class="; the class is the name of the template. So for the main forum page, the line of code is: <div id="content" class="forum_list">, which makes the template forum_list.
Is that not an option in the RM? I have been looking through the RM here and I don't see an "all-time rating" shown.
never mind.. saw it.. you will have to excuse me - been at the E.R. with the wife most of the night.
What threw me off is your screenshot is not like what is in the RM here... the all-time rating is where you actually rate it at.
Looks like it may be a template edit then... I can't provide any help there as I don't have RM. You may want to (while you are waiting on a response) to peruse the associated templates (probably side-bar related) for the RM.