1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Quick Links... why?

Discussion in 'XenForo Suggestions' started by digitalpoint, Dec 30, 2011.

  1. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    Let me preface this by saying that I already know I'm the world's most anal human being, so no need to point that out... :)

    In the navigation bar, some of the tabs give a pop-up menu (for example Members). What is the purpose of the "Quick Links" label in there? What makes those links quick exactly? Or more importantly, do you really think someone would open that menu and not see the label letting them know there are links in it and be like, "Damn, I wish I could click on these menu items, but I guess they aren't links..."

    To *me* it seems like something left over from 10 years ago when DHTML was a novel new thing. Back then they were "quick" because, wow... you could get a menu quickly without needing to go to a table of contents page. But today, I'd say users are past needing a link on a menu labeled as a link.

    I would even argue that the "Members" label within the menu should be removed... I just clicked (or hovered) over the Members link, isn't it kind of redundant that this is a members menu? The title in the menu itself would be more appropriate if it was just an icon you were clicking.

    In the end, does putting a menu title of "Members" and "Quick Links" make the user experience better for users, or is it there for no purpose other than to just have it there?

    Removing both items just looks better/less cluttered in my opinion...

    abdfahim, maszd, CallieJo and 9 others like this.
  2. Digital Doctor

    Digital Doctor Well-Known Member

    OMG. Good pickup. I rarely use the "hover" dropdowns.
    The Title for an already titled Tab = clutter.
    The word quick links = clutter.

    Looks great.
  3. Morgain

    Morgain Well-Known Member

    I already thought this but I thought I was being my usual crazy catlady fuss fuss.
    So I said nothing.
    Glad to see important respectable people think so too ;)
  4. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    I'm not important or respectable (well unless you ask my mom... she thinks I am).

    Coincidentally, it's probably her to blame for me being one of the world's most anal human beings.
  5. Fuhrmann

    Fuhrmann Well-Known Member

    That's a good point to discuss.
    mrGTB likes this.
  6. Morgain

    Morgain Well-Known Member

    The state of my anus right now is .... too much information :(
    <---- earthy lady.

    Digitalpoint cut the modesty. You outrank me - here - your status says so under your avatar. Plus you run a huge, well known board, which is useful to so many admins internationally. I am a small country mouse admin by comparison. I am happy with that - so you just be a good boy now - sit down drink your milk and enjoy your high status! You hear me?

    (Might be a country mouse admin but I'm also heap big matriarch lady boss!)
    alexD likes this.
  7. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    I don't really like milk. :)
  8. Kevin

    Kevin Well-Known Member

    You should always speak up! Others may not agree with you at times but it is often the case that if you've noticed something then the odds are that others have as well.

    Besides, if nothing else, hearing from the 'crazy catlady' folks is good because often little things like this are missed by folks who play with software every day; the 'not seeing the forest for the trees' syndrome. ;)
    Fuhrmann likes this.
  9. Morgain

    Morgain Well-Known Member

    With respect Kevin I thank you for the friendly encouragement but it depends on who is speaking up.
    You see I am VERY observant and very perfectionist. Any coder who works with me knows this!

    As a result I already post in a lot of observations. I deliberately ration them saving some for later, choosing what I think are priority items for now. If I did not do that I assure you you'd get sick of seeing that cute kitten avatar and start wanting to thump it! Also it would be too much criticism too fast for the developers and they deserve to pace it, getting praise for their genius and enjoying it without drowning in a flood of fussy no no do it different. I feel protective of them and protective ofr my community impact generally.

    For many others your advice is perfect. Many people don't speak up nearly enough.
    But I think the number of my posts a week is plenty. I do not want to trigger "oh no not HER again!" That dilutes the effectiveness of my voice anyway.

    But as you see from my signature I value "speaking up" enormously.
  10. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    Well hopefully Mike and Kier don't mind the nitpicking little things like this. Even if this isn't something that is made part of XF natively, it's easy enough to edit out of the template or just hide with CSS. In the end, it's the little thing that give XF it's polish.

    Often, it's little things that make people subconsciously like or dislike something even if they don't know why.

    A perfect example is how Apple designs their Apple stores... down to the screws. They will rip out the sidewalk in front and rebuild it to have symmetrical lines.

    People passing by might not know *why* the store is appealing, just that it is (for all sorts of subconscious reasons).

    I'm not just a coder, I'm also a design freak. lol I've quite literally spent day mucking with some screwy CSS trying to fix a 1px misalignment before.
  11. Morgain

    Morgain Well-Known Member

    Music to my oversensitive designer ears!

    I'm sure Mike and Kier will not mind your critique. Their strength is far too well founded - they genuinely flourish on feedback.
    I'm sorry if I suggested that implication.
  12. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    Normally I gripe about the guts of software. The fact that XF's guts are so well thought out that there is very little fixing needing there... So then you are just left with me wanting to fix completely minor crap like this. lol
  13. Kevin

    Kevin Well-Known Member

    So... now that you've pointed it out, and is now bugging those of obsessed with little things, what is the CSS to hide it in the interim? :p
    Morgain likes this.
  14. erich37

    erich37 Well-Known Member

    not sure if your suggestion would make look XF better or any more symmetrical....

    you are right about the wording for "Quick Links", but on the other hand if you remove that space atop the links, the links would look somehow stucked and bolted together..... as those are to close to each other. The space atop (where is says e.g. "Members") is probably visually or psychologically required......

    Esthetically, it looks nicer as it is currently implemented.

    Probably your suggestion (screenshot) would look nicer if the font-size would be a bit bigger....or if the horizontal space between the links would be bigger, in order to visually distinguish the links?
  15. Morgain

    Morgain Well-Known Member

    Yep precisely. I just told Syndol on another thread that it's quality work that stimulatesw greed for more ... more features.
    It's the actual closeness to perfection that makes us want the rest as well!

    Third rate stuff stimulates little feedback or further demand. People try it out and dump it.
    I guess second rate stuff generates a fair amount of demand but can actually less than the best stuff. If it's second rate you feel like the gap up to perfection is too high. So you either dump iot, or use it and just try to get the priorities in place.

    So glory in the demands put upon you oh ye mighty coders!
    Verily it is the mark of your radiant and blazing status.
  16. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    This should do it...
    .tabMenu .menuHeader {display:none}
    maszd and Kevin like this.
  17. Morgain

    Morgain Well-Known Member

    er for us babes - this goes in EXTRA.css ?

    [5 mins later] Yes it does.
  18. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

  19. Morgain

    Morgain Well-Known Member

    Um any chance while we're on tabs of getting rid of the titchy little arrow for the dropdown?
    I'd be a lot more comfy just touching the tab as a whole to get the dropdown. I hate trying to hit the pesky arrow.
    It would still mean clicking the tab (as opposed to touching/ hovering) would actually open the top level link.

    Apologies if inappropriate on this thread.
    high1976 likes this.
  20. digitalpoint

    digitalpoint Well-Known Member

    I believe you can just add the "NoPopupGadget" class to the link in the template to well... not get the popup gadget (arrow thingie).

    I could be wrong, but I think that's what I did for my forum jump menu and it has no arrow (if you look at the very beginning of this video, the "Forums" tab gives a drop-down even when in the forums):

    Hoffi and dieketzer like this.

Share This Page