To clarify , When I made Mods and made there user group super Moderators they are listed as Members even know they are not in the members group. I had to go to each profile and write in Moderators in the custom field. Shouldn't they have shown up as Moderators because of there group?
Did you make them Moderators by clicking on the "Create New Moderator" button and then on the next screen check "Add Moderator to User Groups: Moderating"?
I just tried that with my test board and it worked fine.
If you only do the first step and don't add them to the user group then they will show in the Staff block but their user title will be from the user group with the highest styling priority; i.e. Registered Users if that's the only user group they are a member of.