AdSense shaved 80%

Anatoliy

Anatoliy

Well-known member
The "Estimated earnings" for June lost 80% after being moved to "Balance" and it drives me mad. All that I can get from them is an reply "It's probably related for invalid traffic". Last month I blocked countries with cloudflare. Didn't help.

Do you experience the same issue? May be someone found the reason and would share the knowledge?

Is it possible that it's the xenforo software that violating adsense's turms of use? I had another forum (IPB) and there was a warning about ajax pagination in the admin -> config area, something like "You have to turn it of if you serve Google Adsense ads". Does xenForo has some similar switch that has to be turned off?

Thanks in advance.
 
Sort by date Sort by votes
It looks like the "after the first post" code (from this guide https://xenforo.com/community/resou...ips-and-visual-overview-of-ad-positions.6797/) was a reason of "invalid traffic" and earnings deduction.

I had 2 ads on thread pages - after the first post and below message list. Impressions, clicks, estimated earnings for each one was very close.
Page CTR was about 10%. Yesterday I turned off the after the first post ad. Page CTR became about 1%.

@Mr. Jinx , do you use after the first post ads from your guide? Does google shave 80% of your earnings?
 
Upvote 1 Downvote
Mr. Jinx said:
Usually I have 1% of invalid traffic.
Click to expand...
I'm jellos 😲
Mr. Jinx said:
because of publishers (you :)) clicking their own ads,
Click to expand...
very funny )
Mr. Jinx said:
It could also be some kind of bot.
Click to expand...
yeah, trying to figure it out in Google Analytics
Mr. Jinx said:
The link I provided also contains a form you can submit if you suspect the invalid traffic is coming from something else.
Click to expand...
Thanks! I didn't know about this option. Submitted. Do hope that it will help.
 
Upvote 1 Downvote

Unexpected discovery.​


So after spending some time in Google Analytics here is what I found:
20% of visits in June came from Coffeyville, Kansas. (My forum has nothing to do with Kansas or Coffeyville)

Here is some stats for Coffeyville, Kansas segment:

Bounce rate: 100%
Avg. Time on Page: 00:00:00

Adsense Page Impressions - 9% of total
Adsense Ads clicked - 91% of total
Adsense revenue - almost exactly that amount that was shaved by Google from my earning.



,
 
Upvote 1 Downvote
Itworx4me said:
What partners are you talking about? Please elaborate. Thanks
Click to expand...

I'd love to find these better partners too. The vast majority of them out there that we have found are just resellers for Google Ad Exchange/OpenX and generally perform worse than going direct unless you have a strong vertical for your forum.
 
Upvote 1 Downvote
HI @Anatoliy I know what you are feeling and those of us with experience with badsense/sadsense for sure had the same in the past. Me too, but I can only give you one tip. If your site's size allows you to ditch Adsense and go with another provider who manages your ad stack go for it as all adsense sites are leaving money on the table.

If you need a good company I can recommend you a few. Just drop me a pm if you wish.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Anatoliy said:
It looks like Google doesn't like an idea to show ads below post container and consider it as invalid traffic.
Click to expand...
There is nothing wrong with placing ads after first post or any other position, as long as it is clear for your users that it is an ad.
For example, it should not look like a regular link that users could click on by mistake. It should also not be placed on auto-reloading pages, etc..
Never heard of this problem so it might be some misconfiguration on your end, or users misbehaving?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Mr. Jinx said:
There is nothing wrong with placing ads after first post or any other position, as long as it is clear for your users that it is an ad.
For example, it should not look like a regular link that users could click on by mistake. It should also not be placed on auto-reloading pages, etc..
Never heard of this problem so it might be some misconfiguration on your end, or users misbehaving?
Click to expand...
It's definitely getting worse. Used to be 10-20% and now some months it can be 50%+ for us. You can look at your past payments and it says how much is deducted for invalid traffic.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Mr. Jinx said:
There is nothing wrong with placing ads after first post or any other position, as long as it is clear for your users that it is an ad.
For example, it should not look like a regular link that users could click on by mistake. It should also not be placed on auto-reloading pages, etc..
Never heard of this problem so it might be some misconfiguration on your end, or users misbehaving?
Click to expand...
Yeah, I understand that in theory there is nothing wrong in placing an ad after a first post container. And I even made top and bottom margins 10px instead of 3 as in your guide, to be sure that ads are not too close and will not violate that rule "ad is too close to an object and fools users".

I have no idea, that's why I started this thread... May be some weird reason like a div with an add is in a div that is in a div... and google somehow fails to read css of those nested divs and somehow it looks to google that the add is places with violation...

Will keep my eye on Page CTR. With after the first post it was 10%. Now with only after thread list ad it's 2.3% so far. SO yeah, it makes sense that Google deducted 80% if normal CTR is 5 times smaller that what I had.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
We have ads at the top/bottom as well as in the middle of threads. The top position performs best by far. Sometimes the deducted amount is more than the total of the other positions. That means, even if google was deducting all of the revenue from the middle/bottom positions, it still wouldn't account for all of our deductions. There's more to this than just a dodgy ad position.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom