[UW] Forum Comments System

Unmaintained [UW] Forum Comments System 1.5

No permission to buy ($35.00)
Compatible XF 2.x versions
Visible branding
This Forum Comments System add-on allows users to post comments under a reply.
These comments work similar way as the vBulletin 5 comments do, only this add-on has already more features than vB5. If you are familiar with vBulletin 5 comments, you will be familiar also with this system.

There are admin permissions settings too. Admin can move comments or create a new thread from a comment.

Notification, alerts are sent no matter where the comment is written, whether it is in a new or an old reply.

The demo version is installed on this website and you can test it in the testing section here: https://ultraweb.co/forums/fcs-testing-area.2/

Moderator’s options are possible to test on request, just send a PM to Admin.

This FCS has been under rigorous testing for almost a month (before posting 1.0). I hate bugs, so I took extreme care to prevent any obvious design flaws or bugs.

Here I've made first example of using this FCS in a forum. There are two threads. Both with exactly the same posts in the same sequence. One thread is with comments and the second is done the traditional XF way, using quotes, without comments (never mind the content, it's just an example not real opinions).

This thread is with comments: What are you listening to? - with comments
- all responses nicely stacked under one post. well organized, space saving, easy to read and see what other people think about the post.

This thread is without comments: This thread is done the traditional XF way using quotes, without comments: What are you listening to? - no comments
- Now, you decide what looks nicer.

There are several ways how you get notified about a posted comment in watched thread.

  • E-mail notification. You will get an email notification. A link in the email will bring you straight to the comment.
  • Alert pop-up window. A link in the alert pop-up window will bring you straight to the comment.

  • Notification in Forums Main category. Normally when a reply is posted, the thread links in the forum are bold informing you that those threads contain unread posts. So the same applies for comments as well. When a comment is posted in a watched thread, the tread link will bump to the top and become bold informing you that you have an unread post. And clicking the bold link or the "time" link, will bring you straight to the comment.

  • Notification in "What's new". The same way as you get informed about replies, you will get also informed about comments in "What's new" section. When a comment is posted in a watched thread, the tread link will bump to the top and become bold informing you that you have an unread post. And clicking the bold link or the "time" link, will bring you straight to the comment.

  • Notification in New Posts. After posting a comment, you will be informed also in "New posts" section.

  • Latest activity. Comments appear in "Latest activity" section as well. A comment link there, will bring you straight to the comment.
  • Postings Comments also included in user's profile under "Postings".
  • A "new" post indicator for comments. Regular feature for a reply works also for a comment to help with the notification.

There are several permission options in this FCS:

  • Enhanced comments deleting. You can use the same functions for deleting comments as for regular replies. You can remove the comment from public view, permanently delete it and also notify the author.
  • Enhanced comment editing. You have the option to edit the comment the same way as a regular reply with a "History" link too.

  • History and revisions for comments. After editing a comment also the "History" button will appear with the same functionality as for a regular reply.
  • Time limit on editing/deleting own comments. Please note that this permission works with the combination of permission "Edit own post/comment". If someone has the permission of editing any comment/post, then this permission will not take effect
  • Moving, Merging and creating replies and threads from comments. With properly set permissions, you can move, merge or create a new thread out of the reply with comments.
You can move a reply with comments and create a new thread out of the reply. The reply will become first post (OP - original post) and the comments will become regular replies.

Or you can move the reply into another thread with two options:

1. Selecting just the reply will move the reply the way it is - comments will stay as comments, except when you are creating a new thread. In that case comments will always turn into replies even if they are not in the first reply.

2. Selecting also the comments - comments will turn into replies when merged with another thread.


  • Moderating functions activated for comments
You can now delete, undelete, approve, unapprove, move and copy comments using the moderation checkbox/moderator's toolbar .

  • Allow/disallow comments per forum. By default FCS add-on will allow comments in all forums. But with this feature, you can disallow posting comments for any forum you want on your website and for any user group.
Navigate to Forums -> Node Permissions (select any forum) -> Select a user group (for example Registered) and you disallow for this group in that forum to post comments.

  • Add-on uninstall with preserving the comments data. The default behaviour is that on uninstall all the data, including the comments, are removed. But with this featrure, you have the option to preserve the comments data by ticking the checkbox "Don't remove comments data" when the uninstall window pops up.​

This way a comment will be converted into a reply with a quote of the reply under which the comment was posted.

Here is an example. This is a reply with comments before uninstalling the FCS add-on:

This is the same reply with converted comments after FCS add-on uninstall:


  • BB code and rich text editing. Creating forum comments allows you to use the rich text editor, full BB code (and Markdown ), smileys and everything that comes with it.
  1. Functions of Reply an Quote links preserved
  2. Mentions support with alerts

  • Reactions added. Default XF reactions also available for forum comments with the same use and functionality.
  1. New permissions "React to comments" added to Groups & permissions
  2. Reactions will be preserved also after uninstall, if "Don't remove comments data." selected.
  3. with notifications in alert window

  • Commenting a comment.
Now you can comment a comment. It works similar way as in the second level for Facebook comments. A comment will include the user's name you are commenting, plus (what Facebook doesn't have), the back button icon when clicked, will bring you to the commented comment.

You can see it in use here.
  • Text editor added also at the end of the comments.

There is a "Comment" link in the post action bar. If you've got a long list of comments then you would have to scroll up to tap the Comment link. As you can see above we now have a "Write a comment..." input directly below the list of comments. Clicking this, as mentioned above, loads the editor which, again, also supports rich formatting.

First release
Last update
5.00 star(s) 1 ratings

More resources from xffutureuser

Latest updates

  1. new functions, commenting a comment, buttons adjusted

    1. Added functionality for comments such as Approve, Spam, Warn and IP buttons. - New...
  2. Small fix

    Cell alignment adjusted to fix issues in some themes.
  3. Text editor also at the end of the comments, new moderating functions activated.

    Improved functionality of the text editor. Now the transformation from a comment to text...

Latest reviews

Impressive how well it goes, an incredible job, thanks for the addon, very useful for my forum, administrators are very happy
Thanks for support. :) Work is in progress already for another update. In case a problem, just send me a PM.